# Are brains necessary?

**URL:** <http://discourse.iapct.org/t/are-brains-necessary/1254>\
**Category:** CSG1997\
**Created:** [April 14, 1997, 5:49am UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/are-brains-necessary/1254 "1997-04-14T05:49:02Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 1\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Richard\_Marken](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/r/9fc348/32.png) [@Richard\_Marken](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Richard_Marken)\
**Post date:** [April 14, 1997, 5:49am UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/are-brains-necessary/1254/1 "1997-04-14T05:49:02Z")

</div>

[From Rick Marken (970413.2230 PDT)]

John Anderson (970413.1730) --

> Would anyone like to comment from a PCT perspective on the attached  
> forwarded post?

Sure:

> Measurments of reaction times of masters in martial arts show that the  
> brain would be far to slow to calculate a response and to proceed it.

Reaction times are a rough measure of the transport lag in a control loop  
that is controlling (by means of the "response" or some variable related  
to the response) a variable that is disturbed by the "stimulus". Whether a  
particular reaction time is relevant to a martial arts expert's ability  
to control a particular variable depends on which controlled variable and  
transport lag you're talking about.

> At least there must be supplementary centres independent from the  
> brain which provide fast information processing in the humen  
> physiological system.

This assumes that a response (like moving the head to the left) that  
compensates for a disturbance (like a swift kick from the right) must be  
calculated between the onset of the disturbance and the onset of the  
corrective response. But this is not the way behavior works. People  
continuously act to control perceptions (like the rate at which images --  
like that of the foot moving towards your head -- are expanding). These  
perceptions are the simultanous result of variations in disturbances (foot  
movement) and responses (movement of the head relative to the oncoming foot,  
for example). In order to compute the response that keeps the perception in  
its reference state the controller would have to determine, continuously, the  
exact contribution of the disturbance to the controlled perception. This  
would, indeed, be a very complex computation. But it is not necessary; the  
control loop can (and does) produce the appropriate response by continuously  
generating responses that are based on the difference between perception  
and reference.

Of course, transport lag puts a limit on the frequency of disturbances that  
can be successfully resisted. But the transport lag in lower level systems  
is quite short (on the order of 10 to 50 msec) so these systems can deal  
with rather high frequency (fast) disturbances -- like the rapidly explanding  
image of a foot that \_would\_ be produced if the head were not moving away  
at nearly the same time.

> An easier theory is that years and years of practice allow martial arts  
> masters and fighter pilots to build a model of their opponent in their  
> own brain

This doesn't seem much easier. A model of the opponent that would actually  
allow one to compute (in advance) the "correct" outputs would be rather  
amazingly complex. It would, for example, have to predict the detailed  
trajectories of the movement of all limbs from any position that the  
opponnet might be in. I have the feeling that this would tax the  
computational capabilities of the fastest super computers.

The basic flaw in this exchange about reaction time and skilled performance  
is the notion that human systems are open loop; that a stimulus is followed,  
after some delay (RT), by the appropriate response. What is ignored is that  
the actual cause of the response -- the sensory effect of the stimulus -- is  
being affected by the stimulus AND THE RESPONSE at the same time. That is,  
the situation is:

S --\>s--\>| Human|--\>R  
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;^ (RT) |

> **···**
>
> > &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;\>
> 
> &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;--------------
> 
> where S is the stimulus, s is the controlled sensory effect of the stimulus  
> (and response) and R is the response. The RT delay occurs IN THE LOOP!
> 
> NOT
> 
> S --\>s--\>| Human|--\>R  
> &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;(RT)
> 
> whre the RT delay is time spent producing the R that will correct for S  
> \_in the future\_.
> 
> Actually, these two discussants have proposed the two main S-R models  
> of control: information processing and model based output generation.  
> This is interesting because it shows that people will come up with  
> the same kinds of explanations of behavior when they think of behavior  
> in terms of the same underlying model -- S-R (or input-output or whatever  
> you want to call it).
> 
> Best
> 
> Rick
