# Beaver Tale, Unexpected Consequences

**URL:** <http://discourse.iapct.org/t/beaver-tale-unexpected-consequences/1589>\
**Category:** CSG1993\
**Created:** [January 30, 1993, 11:03pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/beaver-tale-unexpected-consequences/1589 "1993-01-30T23:03:00Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 1\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Henry\_James\_Bicycles](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/h/57b2e6/32.png) [@Henry\_James\_Bicycles](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Henry_James_Bicycles)\
**Post date:** [January 30, 1993, 11:03pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/beaver-tale-unexpected-consequences/1589/1 "1993-01-30T23:03:00Z")

</div>

[From Hank Folson (930130)]

I saw the world record beaver lodge (25' high) in northern Manitoba after  
the pond it was in had been drained to make way for a new railroad line. I  
still remember that the stream was bordered by rock, and where the dam had  
been was very narrow, so the beaver could add to the height without a  
great deal of effort. I suspect that whatever beavers' reference levels  
for dam building are, the geography here led to a very deep pond being  
easily built, and so the world's tallest beaver house was built.

I notice in charts showing the aspects of a control system, there is often  
a box marked "Unexpected Consequences". I don't think this beaver wanted  
to build the world's largest beaver lodge, but was just controlling for  
whatever beavers control for, and this huge house was just an unexpected  
consequence of building where he built. A lot of the observations quoted  
in Greg's post are really just unexpected consequences of a control system  
controlling.

As to half girdled trees, I wonder if the beaver is trying to ensure a  
supply of readily available material for repairing damn dam damage? Just  
cutting down trees to have for repairs will not work, as the trees will  
quickly rot and be useless. By half cutting them, the trees stay upright,  
yet can felled in a hurry should the dam break, allowing water to escape  
and exposing the lodge to predators. This of course is not as romantic and  
selfless as the quote Greg posted, but may be better control theory. It  
would be interesting to see if there is any correlation between number of  
half-girdled trees and the size of the dam. I agree intuitively with Bill  
that half girdled trees won't be found during dam construction.

Back in my days of believing in instincts, I was fascinated that if a  
beaver has created about a 10' deep pond, it will have about 5 dams along  
the stream, each providing about a 2' increase in water level. Thus the  
failure of any dam results in only a 2' lowering of water level. In  
addition, each dam sees only the net loading of 2' of water, making  
construction much less critical than a single dam with a 10' head of water  
I have no idea how the beaver figures this all out. Beavers with goals for  
a series of small dams might survive better, per Darwin, than beavers that  
build one big monster dam. Or it may simply be that with their limited  
capabilities, beavers can't construct a dam to hold more than so many feet  
of water reliably. Perhaps it is as simple as having a program of building  
2' high dams. Then if the pond depth does not satisfy some reference  
level, another dam is built upstream to raise the level another 2', and  
so on until the reference level for pond depth is satisfied. Not very  
romantic, but then neither are orange colored teeth (to non-beavers).

Has anyone ever tried to get naturalists interested in PCT? Most nature  
films, books and TV programs I have seen rely pretty heavily on a  
combination of romance and educated guesses based on observations from  
the external viewers' point of view, not the furry little control system's.

Hank Folson  
Henry James Bicycles, Inc. 704 Elvira Avenue, Redondo Beach, CA 90277  
310-540-1552 (Day & Eve.) MCI MAIL: 509-6370 Internet: [5096370@MCIMAIL.COM](mailto:5096370@MCIMAIL.COM)
