# Challenge 2, cont's

**URL:** <http://discourse.iapct.org/t/challenge-2-conts/2421>\
**Category:** CSG1993\
**Created:** [April 17, 1993, 11:30pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/challenge-2-conts/2421 "1993-04-17T23:30:02Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 1\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![William\_T\_Powers2](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/w/c67d28/32.png) [@William\_T\_Powers2](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/William_T_Powers2)\
**Post date:** [April 17, 1993, 11:30pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/challenge-2-conts/2421/1 "1993-04-17T23:30:02Z")

</div>

[From Bill Powers (930417.1530)]

Greg Williams (930416-2) --

In the last post to you, I applied a number of disturbances,  
assuming that your goal was to maintain that the Test had not met  
your requirements.

Basically I just kept asserting that you had agreed, and the  
evidence I had presented was sufficient, and that you  
acknowledged that, and that therefore you had accepted that I had  
met the challenge.

In today's post, you clearly rejected every such claim, giving  
your reasons for the rejection and in general trying to correct  
the false impression of your position that I was giving.

So I deduce that there is some controlled perception here, which  
was disturbed by my assertions, your statements today being  
designed to protect correct some effect of that disturbance. I  
would guess that this reference perception is the perception that  
the challenge has not been met.

To say that this is your reference level for that perception is  
not to say that the desired level of the perception was  
established arbitrarily or simply to be wilfully contrary. It is  
to say only that for whatever reason, you have decided that this  
perception belongs in that state, and deserves to be maintained  
in that state, at least for now, until there is some higher-level  
reason for changing it. If I were trying to persuade you that you  
aren't living near Gravel Switch, KY, and you cared to set me  
straight, much the same thing would happen. Anything that I said  
to intimate that you were not living there would be perceived,  
for very good reasons, as erroneous -- as different from the fact  
that you choose to accept about where you do live. So your  
perception of where you live is not just a perception, it is a  
\_reference\_ perception. If you awoke one morning to discover that  
you own and live in a house in Northbrook, IL, this perception  
would constitute a huge error, for you wouldn't recall having  
moved there, and you would KNOW that you live in Gravel Switch.  
That is your reference picture of where you live, not simply a  
neutral observation, changeable merely by a change in  
circumstances.

We have reasons for choosing to set our reference perceptions as  
we do. They have have been set by higher-level systems, for their  
own purposes. When we began this challenge, you had already  
expressed doubts about the ability of the Test to uncover  
controlled variables in the wild. To some extent you had already  
accepted this as a fact. This fact was consistent with many of  
your higher-level perceptions. That is one reason that you issued  
the challenge; you had doubts about the Test. The outcome was a  
belief, or hunch, or opinion, that the Test would fail under the  
uncontrolled conditions of network correspondence. Whether you  
labeled it as such or not, this became a reference perception:  
The test cannot work under these conditions. If you say it will,  
you said to me, then prove it, if you can.

Instead of picking some easy subject, like your intention to  
publish the next Closed Loop with certain subject matter in it, I  
chose to meet the challenge head on, by making the challenge  
itself the object of the Test. You see, I like a challenge, too.

The interesting thing that emerged was that quite involuntarily  
you started finding reasons for fending off any direct approach  
to the question of why you were responding as you were. Because  
you doubted that the Test could succeed, particularly not easily,  
you countered all my questions and suggestions so as to keep them  
from eliciting a directly opposing response. This seemed  
perfectly reasonable to you: after all, the Test is difficult to  
apply, and my failures to break through simply supported that  
idea. Each time we went around, you satisfied yourself that I had  
not yet met the challenge. The opinion with which you started was  
functioning as a reference signal, and the appended control  
system was working just as it should.

After the hiatus, I wrote once again, this time exerting a  
blatantly obvious disturbance by claiming that you had actually  
agreed that the challenge had been met. This brought forth the  
most direct denial of all: you stated a number of times that this  
was false, that it had not been met. If you had agreed with me,  
that would have constituted an error for you, a wrongness. You  
might have dealt with that wrongness just by concluding that I  
had abandoned logic altogether, or was indulging in wishful  
thinking, and opted out of the whole thing. But evidently you  
considered my statements to be worth correcting, and did so.

So once again, my disturbance of what I considered to be a  
controlled variable for you resulted in opposition that  
counteracted the disturbance. I can tell that I'm in the same  
ballpark as one of your controlled variables. There are, of  
course, many ways to describe a controlled variable, and I don't  
know if you would describe it the same way I do. At least I have  
a pragmatically useful way of characterizing it, and if this were  
the end of the matter I could predict opposition from you when I  
make statements of certain kinds, and none (relating to the same  
controlled variable) when I talk about other things with you. If  
I said "Gee, it's pretty hard to apply the test here," I would  
not anticipate opposition. So I would know at least something  
functionally and practically equivalent to this one sample of  
your controlled variables. On later occasions I might find no  
resistance where I expected it, and refine my definition further,  
and perhaps get a little closer.

In the Coin Game, one person might guess that the other was  
creating a "zig-zag" or the letter "Z", while the other person  
insisted that the target pattern was actually an "N". If you look  
at the coins instead of listening to the names, you can see that  
all these terms describe the same pattern in different  
orientations. The Test reveals the correct pattern, but not  
necessarily the same name of the pattern that the other was  
thinking of.

So I think I see the pattern in your control behavior, and I have  
given a name to it, but I don't know how you would describe it.  
To discover more in that regard, the person applying the Test  
would have to see the behavior in a larger context, and look at  
higher levels of controlled variables.

The easiest way to demonstrate a reference perception in someone  
else is to wait for a Tuesday, and say "This is Monday, isn't  
it?" If the person is controlling for it being Tuesday, you'll  
get a corrective answer. If you insist that it must be Monday,  
you'll get more elaborate corrections ("Look, here's today's  
newspaper -- look at the date"). Now maybe the person really  
wants you to be set aright, but that's an equivalent reference  
signal, and could be distinguished if you thought of it and  
varied the Test. And most people, when confronted with a  
statement as to what day of the week it is, will experience a  
little doubt, a little error, because it's not that easy to  
\_verify\_ what the day is right off the bat. For a lot of us,  
there is some relief in finding that we had been under the  
impression that today is Tuesday, and it actually is Tuesday.  
It's that little frisson that occurs when someone suggests that  
it's Monday that tells us that Tuesday isn't just a perception of  
the existing state of affairs. It's a reference signal that we  
advance to its next setting once a day -- usually, but not  
always, correctly.

If I wanted to find out why you are controlling the variable in  
question here, I would begin applying disturbances to the idea  
that subjective impressions are not sufficient evidence for a  
scientific test. I might just insist that they are quite  
sufficient, or even more directly, intimate that YOU think they  
are quite sufficient. Having established, more or less, that this  
opinion \_is\_ a reference level, perhaps I would try to go still  
more more level higher, trying to see what would be disturbed if  
this opinion were to change. But by that time we could hardly do  
without a continuous face-to-face interchange -- and an audience  
might not be appropriate.

Notice that my intent is never to prove that this is a "wrong"  
setting for a reference level. It is right in terms of the  
higher-level perceptions that it is there to support. Applying  
disturbances might give the impression that I think it is wrong,  
but that is not true. I am simply trying to see whether  
disturbances will be opposed. If they are opposed, then I am  
disturbing a controlled variable. Perhaps by varying my  
disturbances in a clever enough way, I can arrive at a  
pragmatically correct understanding of it. Basically, I don't  
care what the reference level is, or argue with it; I simply want  
to identify it.

And perhaps now you might be willing to concede that it's not as  
hard as it seems.

Best

Bill P.
