[From Rick Marken (980615.0850)]
i.kurtzer (980615.0000) --
Therefore, ALL interactions about a common CV will fall under
coersion given a suitable gain difference.
Yes. I agree.
Does that not seem strange?
Yes. It does not seem strange.
Does that make for a very strange taxonomy with helping as a
subclass of coersion?
Maybe it's surprising. But I wouldn't call it "strange". Many of
the interactions that people call "helping" are clearly examples
of coercion (as I have defined it). For example, suppose I want
to help you become a better person by forcing you to spend more
time in school and less time rolling around on your skate board.
Am I helping you? Or am I coercing? I can call what I'm doing
"helping" but you (as the victim of my "help") know that I am really
coercing. Agents of the government will arrest me if I smoke dope
in the privacy of my own backyard. They think they are helping me
by keeping me away from the evils of drugs. Of course, they are
really just coercing me into not taking the drugs I want to take
(I am actually not interested in taking drugs but I have seen
this kind of "help" given to friends who _were_). I'm sure you can
think of many more examples.
It's not rare for "coersion" to be done in the name of "helping";
it would be nice if the RTP program could avoid this hypocricy.
In PCT, real "helping" would involve making it possible for the
helpee to control what s/he wants to control. Any direct efforts
to help the helpee bring a controlled variable to it's reference,
however, would almost certainly lead to conflict (due to control
system "parallax"; the helper sees the controlled variable from
a different point of view than the helpee so the helper is likely
to be trying to help bring the controlled variable to the "wrong"
reference state).
I think PCT has some interesting implications regarding how we
might go about trying to help people. Maybe a discussion of
helping, from a PCT perspective, would be helpful;-)
Best
Rick
···
--
Richard S. Marken Phone or Fax: 310 474-0313
Life Learning Associates e-mail: rmarken@earthlink.net
http://home.earthlink.net/~rmarken