Collective perceptions, Five Easy Pieces

[From Rick Marken (2000.03.04.1100)]

Paul Stokes (2000.03.02.00.2329 GMT)

Dialogue can be a royal road to knowledge.

Only to knowledge of each others' points of view; dialog
reveals the difference between points of view when there
are points of contention (conflict). But real knowledge --
knowledge of whether one's point of view is a valid model
of reality -- comes only from scientific test (comparing
the behavior of a mathematical model, that represents one's
point of view, to the behavior of reality). It's this latter
approach to knowledge that has been slargely absent from CSGNet.

Science is if anything a co-operative enterprise. But then
PCT has serious doubts about that possibility.

PCT explains what cooperation is and how it works. See the paper
on economic cooperation I presented at the CSG meeting last year
(http://home.earthlink.net/~rmarken/ConfEcon.html). It includes
a simple model of cooperation. Modeling is one half of the
scientific enterprise; the other half is observation. Science is
a dialog with nature, not with other people. Contrary to what
has apparently become a popular belief, science is _not_ done
by writing books; that's how _religion_ is done.

In this regard I think Bill completely exaggerates the
incidence of breakdown.

You may be right. But the way to find out is by doing research.
This discussion would be much more interesting (and perhaps less
contentious) if it were based on data, not just imagination.

You people have a lot to learn about how real sciences make
progress in the real world.

I thought they make progress by building models and testing
the predictions of those models in very carefully performed
experiments. Isn't that basically it?

Me:

By the way, does anyone out there know of any other working
model of the macro economy...

Martin Taylor (2000.03.04 11:54) --

Not a working model in the sense of a simulation, but an analytic
description in terms of processes and mechanisms that could
probably be turned into a working model with current computers--
Samuel Bagno, IRE Conference record 1955 Part 4. I recently got
permission from the IEEE to reproduce this paper on my Web site

Thanks. But there seems to be no text on the pages yet. All I
see is a pointer to a GIF image.

Best

Rick

···

--
Richard S. Marken Phone or Fax: 310 474-0313
Life Learning Associates e-mail: rmarken@earthlink.net
http://home.earthlink.net/~rmarken/

Rick,

Thanks a lot for picking up on my remarks. You make some salutary points, of
course, which are good. You also clarify some real points of divergence,
which is also important.

Don't run down dialogue: it really is important!

Best wishes.

Paul

[From Rick Marken (2000.03.05.0930)]

Paul A. Stokes (2000.03.05) --

You make some salutary points, of course, which
are good.

Thanks :slight_smile:

You also clarify some real points of divergence,
which is also important.

Where do we diverge? Are they irreconcilable divergences?

Don't run down dialogue: it really is important!

I agree that dialog is important; that's why I like to
dialog on CSGNet. The point of my earlier post was not
that dialog is important. My point was that dialog (between
people) is not the basis of scientific understanding. When
dialog is used for scientific understanding I think it's
called "sophistry".

Dialog (and I think this follows from PCT) can help us
understand what we are each trying to say. In this case,
diagreements are more useful than agreements; we know that
there is a misunderstanding when there is disagreement but
we can only _hope_ that there is understanding when
there is agreement. (I think this was the point Bill was
trying to make when your dialog broke down).

Dialog is important to me because it helps me understand what
Bill's model of behavior actually _is_ and how to test it. But
dialog doesn't (and can't) tell me whether Bill's model is
actually a better explanation of behavior than others. To find
that out I have to do science -- the dialog with nature. Dialog
with Bill helps me understand what PCT is; science (the
dialog with nature) convinces me (every time, so far) that
PCT right.

Best

Rick

···

--
Richard S. Marken Phone or Fax: 310 474-0313
Life Learning Associates e-mail: rmarken@earthlink.net
http://home.earthlink.net/~rmarken/