[From Rick Marken (930413.2000)]
Ken Hacker [930412] to Tom Bourbon --
I would like to propose the following kind of experiment. Let me suggest
a research question involving real people talking, not doing exercises,
but relating verbally and nonverbally to accomplish some task. Let us
then study and describe their behaviors from two points of view: the
variable analytic and the PCT. Let's see what the differences are in all
areas of study design, data gathering, and data interpretation.
Well, now it's my turn to completely agree with Ken Hacker.
I would suggest something like a version of the study Tom
describes in his ABS paper. But, since you (Ken) are the comm-
unication expert, I think it would be appropriate for you to
propose the research question, describe a task to test it and
the results expected on the basis of "variable analytic" theory.
Then we can take a stab at it from the PCT side.
En garde?
Best
Rick
From Tom Bourbon [930414.1253 CDT]
Rick MArken (930413.2000) posted Re a message from Ken HAcker (930412),
who was replying to me. Ken suggested that we examine an experimental
instance of communication and analyze it using the tools of two theories,
varible analytic theory and PCT. Rick thought that was a good idea, and
so do I.
Ken, if you want to use an example like the one I describe in the ABS
article, that is fine, but I also agree with Rick that you should be
free to select any example or condition you wish. Does that sound fair?
Tom Bourbon
Ken Hacker [930414]
Tom and Rick, Yes, the idea sound fair. I propose the test not as any
sort of contest, but only as an attempt to observe what the two approaches
do and find and describe differently. It will be instructive to me as I
eventually try to explain to other communication scientists what it is that
PCT says about social interaction. I just read a reference to Bill Powers
in my textbook for a graduate seminar in organizational communication. The
author implies that what Bill talks about as comparators and other internal
signal sensors are "hypothetical." Well, at least it's a start. 99% of
the other people in my discipline probably think he is designing robots!
Anyway, I will come up with an experiment proposal in the next few days.
KEN