# Comparing views of behavior

**URL:** <http://discourse.iapct.org/t/comparing-views-of-behavior/2707>\
**Category:** CSG1995\
**Created:** [June 5, 1995, 8:40pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/comparing-views-of-behavior/2707 "1995-06-05T20:40:03Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 2\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Richard\_Marken](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/r/9fc348/32.png) [@Richard\_Marken](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Richard_Marken)\
**Post date:** [June 5, 1995, 8:40pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/comparing-views-of-behavior/2707/1 "1995-06-05T20:40:03Z")

</div>

[From Rick Marken (950605.1330)]

Bruce Abbott (950604.1510 EST) --

> The current [non-PCT] view [of behavior] seems to make logical sense,  
> appears to be supported by common sense and by considerable data, and  
> provides a framework for new research...So when some other proposal comes  
> along, you may give it a quick once-over, but you probably will not invest  
> the effort needed to really understand it and to work out its implications.

I'm wondering whether the current view of behavior is anything more than just  
that -- a view. I say this because I think it is true that most psychologists  
would, indeed, agree that the current view is supported by considerable  
data (and, apparently, rejected by none).

I think of the "current view" in the behavioral sciences as any version of  
the cause-effect model of behavior: S-R, selection by consequences, output  
generation. If behavior is, indeed, the control of perception, then it is  
rather surprising that there is not more data that rejects the current view.  
Although the behavior of a control system can look like S-R, selection by  
consequences or output generation, the behavior of a control system is VERY  
different than an S-R, selection by consequences or output generation \_model\_  
of behavior.

The fact that the results of virtually all the studies that have been done in  
the behavioral sciences are seen as being consistent with the current view  
suggests, to me, that people are not really comparing these results to the  
behavior of a working model that embodies the current view; they are only  
looking for qualitative match between what the see and what they think they  
should see. So, the fact that there is SOME relationship between an  
independent and a dependent variable, for example, is enough to prove that  
the basic assumptions of the cause-effect model are correct; stimuli DO cause  
variations in behavior.

I think this qualitative approach to evaluating theories is one reason why we  
(pCTers) are often accused of developing "straw man" theories when we try to  
test working versions of S- R, selection by consequences and output  
generation models against our experimental results. The models we develop  
based on our understanding of the "current view" always fail - - rather  
dramatically in most cases -- and I don't think conventional behavioral  
scientists are used to this; they certainly don't expect to see their  
"current view" of behavior just flat out rejected by the data. They are used  
to seeing data that is ALWAYS consistent with their view -- data that can be  
explained (verbally) and accounted for (by curve fitting).

So I'm not sure that any amount of data could convince conventional  
psychologists that their current view is wrong. Any result produced in a PCT  
experiment could be "explained" by the conventional view. If the data clearly  
reject the current view, conventional psychologists can always say that our  
model is a "straw man". This is what happened to Tom Bourbon and Bill Powers  
in their paper demonstrating the inablity of S-R and output generation  
models to account for the simplest tracking behavior. It is what happened  
to me in a paper demonstrating the inability of a selection by consequences  
model to account for goal directed behavior when the consequences of actions  
are random.

I guess what I'm saying is that most conventional behavioral science is  
actually pre-scientific and, thus, not really vulnerable to disproof. I  
suppose I would change my mind about this if some conventional behavioral  
scientist would propose a working model (based on the current view) of some  
behavior that we could test against PCT. Does anyone know of such a model?

Best

Rick

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Bill\_Leach1](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/b/848f3c/32.png) [@Bill\_Leach1](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Bill_Leach1)\
**Post date:** [June 7, 1995, 5:57am UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/comparing-views-of-behavior/2707/2 "1995-06-07T05:57:53Z")

</div>

\<[Bill Leach 950606.19:49 U.S. Eastern Time Zone]

> [From Rick Marken (950605.1330)]

> I'm wondering whether the current view of behavior is anything more than  
> just that -- a view. I say this because I think it is true that most  
> psychologists would, indeed, agree that the current view is supported by  
> considerable data (and, apparently, rejected by none).

I think this is a bit of an overstatement. Many pyschologists have been  
bemoning the accuracy and suitability of existing theories of behaviour  
for quite a number of years now.

Most of the "pop" psychologists flatly reject the implications of current  
fundamental theory. Even if those recognizing "control theory" are  
mostly off their A\*\*s\*\* as far as any sort of real understanding of the  
theory, most of them do recognize that living systems do "attempt" to  
control their own environments (recognize now and then anyway). Of  
course these same folks are not going to listen much to PCT either!

> The fact that the results of virtually all the studies that have been  
> done in the behavioral sciences are seen as being consistent with the  
> current view suggests, to me, that people are not really comparing these  
> results to the behavior of a working model that embodies the current  
> view; they are only looking for qualitative match between what the see  
> and what they think they should see. So, the fact that there is SOME  
> relationship between an ...

You don't mean to tell me that this surprises you! :-0

Some of the very serious problems are that these folks do NOT expect  
highly correlative data. They honestly believe that in their field  
results consistant to within 5% is a "pipe dream".

They HAVE been able to obtain a great deal of information that is "true"  
and even a significant amount that is \_true\_.

In the sense that we already complain about the loose meaning of the term  
behaviour, much of the information about "behaviour" is "true" in that  
results obtained are repeatable in the commercial world over sufficiently  
large numbers of people to about the same degree as is predicted by  
research (36% of the people studied really do prefer Coke).

-bill
