[From Bruce Nevin (2000.0505.1111 EDT)]
Mike Acree (2000.0510.0953 PDT)--
>>But none of this constitutes
>evidence that cooperation is _winning out over_ competition, which is quite
>a different claim.Hm. How did we come to pit cooperation against competition? Are they in
competition with each other?The inference that they are in competition (or perhaps meta-competition?)
is of course specious. "Cooperation" and "Competition" are not entities
capable of either cooperating or competing with one another.
I agree with your statement here. What I think the original author meant
was the following:
Some entities with differing capabilities and resources find it in their
best interests, through division of labor to "cooperate". Both entities
are left in a superior position due to cooperation than working
independently or in direct conflict.
So suppose you have "man" who is capable of both types of behavior. We
can claim that groups of men engaging in "cooperative" behavior will on
average prosper more than groups of men who operate in "conflict". (It is
probably more accurate to claim only that any that the members of any
particular group of men will prosper more under cooperation than these
same members would under a situation of conflict. Ludwig von Mises would
agree.)
I think using the word "competition" as a synonym for "conflict" is very
misleading. Competition can occur even in cooperative circumstances, such
as the free market. The competition is among producers to best meet the
needs of consumers. Resources are scare, thus there will be competition
for those resources. However, in a cooperative setting, there is the
possibility of conflict-free exchange of resources to the betterment of
both parties. This is because individuals value the same resources
differently.
> Are we sure the attribution is less specious when we're talking about
control systems? Each is controlling input variables. When control of input
<a> by control system A inteferes with control of input <b> by control
system B, they are in conflict. If they do not resolve the conflict, they
are in competition. If they resolve the conflict so that one is able to
control and the other not, they were in competition, and one of them "won"
(the one that controls successfully). If they resolve the conflict so that
each is able to control "happily" (so to speak), they are in cooperation.
The enormous gray area (showing how much all of this is in the eye of an
external observer) includes all kinds of cases in which one or both finds
other, non-conflicting means of controlling higher-level variables
successfully. If one changes, did one "give up" or "lose"?
In your analysis here, I believe you neglect the main benefit of
cooperation. It isn't just that the two control systems resolve a
conflict, but that in fact that both control systems are able to control
-better- their individual perceptions because of the mechanisms of
cooperation.
The potential benefits of cooperation form the foundation of a rational
basis for rules of morality. The case where an individual or group of
individuals has sufficient power that they can obtain more by force or
conflict than by cooperation is a difficult issue. Perhaps one could
appeal to historical interpretation to demonstrate that even where one is
apparently in this case, the aggressor is still worse off in the long run,
but I don't have much hope for that.
Steve Jilcott
···
At 09:56 AM 05/01/2000 -0700, Michael Acree UCSF wrote: