CSGnet future and the future f PCT

[Martin Taylor 2017.06.23.00.43]

[From Rick Marken (2017.06.22.1700)

See [Martin Taylor 2017.06.21.07.56] for a carefully prepared set of

suggestions with my reasons for my making them.

Given what you have written above, I do not believe you opened that

message, because what you say is “pretty clear” about what I believe
has very little correspondence with what I wrote there. “* It seems
pretty clear to me that what Martin believed was driving people
away from CSGNet was not the uncivil tone of the discussions but,
rather, the fact that there was disagreement about the merits of
proposed contributions to PCT made by newcomers to CSGNet.”

···

Bruce Nevin (201.06.17.16:19
ET)

              BN: There is nothing in Martin's 'birthday

curmudgeon’ post (Martin Taylor 2016.06.14.00.05) that
says or implies "Rick Marken is to blame for driving
people away from CSG-net. The closest thing to it is
his mention of one episode (“Rick rather strongly
accused me of trying to improve PCT in lieu of showing
why whatever the suggested improvement was was
actually a non-starter”).

RM: Well, there was also this:

            BN Over the years many clever

people from other disciplines who seemed to offer the
possibility of important advances to PCT have been
turned – or perhaps “driven” is a better word – away
from CSGnet, though not always from PCT. I think most
recently of Alex Gomez-Marin and I see it being done
currently to Eetu Pikkarainen, a person whose acumen I
have learned to admire from our interactions outside of
CSGnet.

          RM:  I was the only one who apparently drove Alex away

with my PCT interpretation of the power law; everyone else
seemed to agree with Alex that my analysis was “bullshit”.
I believe I am also the one who corrected Eetu’s
misconceptions about PCT so I’m pretty sure I’m the one
Martn had in mind as the one currently driving Eetu away.

              BN: I read Martin's post differently from you, and

I agree with what I understand him to be saying. There
is a recurrent problem of tone and manner on CSG-net.

          RM: It seems pretty clear to me that what Martin

believed was driving people away from CSGNet was not the
uncivil tone of the discussions but, rather, the fact that
there was disagreement about the merits of proposed
contributions to PCT made by newcomers to CSGNet. If it
were the tone that bothered Martin I don’t think I would
have been the only one he mentioned in his post. I may be
bad (I don’t think I am but you can’t control the way
people perceive you) but surely there are others who are
as bad or even worse in terms of tone. But more on this
when I reply to some other posts on this thread that I am
way behind on.

BN: I want us to focus on how to fix it.

RM: I would love to hear specific suggestions.

          And why don't you think that some of the blame for

driving people away from CSGNet might be in the often
insulting and sometimes profane replies I get to my posts.