[From Rick Marken (980211.0740)]
Oded Maler (980211) --
The dismissal of all other research as "it tells us nothing",
combined with the naive beliefs on the unlimited applicability
of the test, seems to reflect a non-scientific local-patriotic
attitude, a miniaturized version of the attitudes of the
scientific church which rejects PCT.
PCT doesn't dismiss "all other research as 'it tells us nothing'".
PCT shows that a particular approach to studying the behavior of
organisms (the approach used in conventional social science) tells
us nothing about the organism itself if the organism is a control
system. The behavioral illusion demo at
http://home.earthlink.net/~rmarken/demos.html explains why this is the
case.
So whatever "dismissing" of research we do in PCT, it is done on
the basis of theory and observation. If you don't like the
"dismissing of other research" that PCT implies, then I think
it behooves you to explain (and demonstrate) what is wrong with
the behavioral illusion demo, not what is wrong with me (sych
as my "non-scientific local-patriotic attitude").
The basic ideas of PCT are beautiful, and it is rather sad that no
serious full-time scientific community has been formed around them.
Your rhetoric on the subject is sometimes very amusing and enjoyable
to read but its fundamentalistic character is counter-productive.
Ok. So no member of the "serious full-time scientific community"
has embraced PCT and it's all because of my me. But you seem to know
an awful lot about this so can you tell me who was scaring these
people away for the 20 years prior to my arrival on the PCT scene?
Martin Taylor (980211 0:21) --
The message of PCT is a wonderful message. It is the translation
[me Rick the Terrible] of that message into the language of the
messenger that sometimes is troublesome.
The message of the behavioral illusion is that if there is a
possibility that the objects of your study are control systems
then a prerequisite to understanding their behavior is determining
what variables they are controlling. You seem to think that this
message doesn't pertain to conventional psychophysical experiments
(like the forced choice procedure you mentioned). Where's the
language problem?
Best
Rick
···
--
Richard S. Marken Phone or Fax: 310 474-0313
Life Learning Associates e-mail: rmarken@earthlink.net
http://home.earthlink.net/~rmarken