Deconstructing the messenger, catching up

[From Rick Marken (980211.0740)]

Oded Maler (980211) --

The dismissal of all other research as "it tells us nothing",
combined with the naive beliefs on the unlimited applicability
of the test, seems to reflect a non-scientific local-patriotic
attitude, a miniaturized version of the attitudes of the
scientific church which rejects PCT.

PCT doesn't dismiss "all other research as 'it tells us nothing'".
PCT shows that a particular approach to studying the behavior of
organisms (the approach used in conventional social science) tells
us nothing about the organism itself if the organism is a control
system. The behavioral illusion demo at
http://home.earthlink.net/~rmarken/demos.html explains why this is the
case.

So whatever "dismissing" of research we do in PCT, it is done on
the basis of theory and observation. If you don't like the
"dismissing of other research" that PCT implies, then I think
it behooves you to explain (and demonstrate) what is wrong with
the behavioral illusion demo, not what is wrong with me (sych
as my "non-scientific local-patriotic attitude").

The basic ideas of PCT are beautiful, and it is rather sad that no
serious full-time scientific community has been formed around them.
Your rhetoric on the subject is sometimes very amusing and enjoyable
to read but its fundamentalistic character is counter-productive.

Ok. So no member of the "serious full-time scientific community"
has embraced PCT and it's all because of my me. But you seem to know
an awful lot about this so can you tell me who was scaring these
people away for the 20 years prior to my arrival on the PCT scene?

Martin Taylor (980211 0:21) --

The message of PCT is a wonderful message. It is the translation
[me Rick the Terrible] of that message into the language of the
messenger that sometimes is troublesome.

The message of the behavioral illusion is that if there is a
possibility that the objects of your study are control systems
then a prerequisite to understanding their behavior is determining
what variables they are controlling. You seem to think that this
message doesn't pertain to conventional psychophysical experiments
(like the forced choice procedure you mentioned). Where's the
language problem?

Best

Rick

···

--
Richard S. Marken Phone or Fax: 310 474-0313
Life Learning Associates e-mail: rmarken@earthlink.net
http://home.earthlink.net/~rmarken

[From Oded Maler (980212)]

(Rick Marken (980211.0740)]

Oded Maler (980211) --

Ok. So no member of the "serious full-time scientific community"
has embraced PCT and it's all because of my me. But you seem to know
an awful lot about this so can you tell me who was scaring these
people away for the 20 years prior to my arrival on the PCT scene?

I don't know - I only became aware of PCT six years ago via this
group. The reasons for the past are rather obvious: Bill P. is not a
Prof. in some respectable university, and this is a sufficient
condition for not being able to dictatate the agenda of any
established scientific community. This is a sad fact of life, no value
judgement of course. But since the existence of CSG-L, my observation
is that you try to dismiss the contribution of serious persons,
committed to the study of human behavior, such as Martin and Bruce A.
for reasons that have little to do with truth seeking.

  (Rick Marken (980211.0840)]

   Martin Taylor (980211 0:21) --

   > Huh? What is it about PCT I am supposed not to like? I guess you
   > will have to use the method of levels on me to make me aware of
   > something that I perceive but am unaware of.

  The method of levels is not necessary. The Test is appropriate
  here. One thing you don't like about PCT are the implications
  of the _behavioral illusion_ for conventional psychological
  research; you act as though the implications of this illusion
  (the existence of which is known only because of PCT) are a
  disturbance to some perception you are controlling. It seems to
  me that the perception you are controlling is rather obvious:
  "the merits of conventional psychophysical research" (I've
  been Testing this hypothesis about what you are controlling
  several years now and it has yet to fail the Test).

  There is nothing "wrong" with controlling for this variable,
  by the way. I just wish you would stop blaming one source
  of disturbance to it (me;-)) for the fact that the behavioral
  illusion is a disturbance to what you are controlling.

I think this is the best demonstration of the limits of the test. If
the tester himself controls for NOT(A), where A is some perception in
his own private hierarchy, he will be very likely to interpret any
resistance to his claims as controlling for A by the subject, while
the subject might not have a perception for A at all.

Regrads,

--Oded

[From Rick Marken (980212.0750)]

Oded Maler (980212) --

But since the existence of CSG-L, my observation is that you
try to dismiss the contribution of serious persons, committed to
the study of human behavior, such as Martin and Bruce A. for
reasons that have little to do with truth seeking.

First, I dismiss my own contribitions to the study of behavior as
readily as I dismiss thoses of Martin, Bruce A. or anyone else
who made those "contributions" in the context of the wrong model
of living systems (the cause-effect models).

Second, Bill Powers, Tom Bourbon, Richard Kennaway and everyone
else who understands what's going on with PCT dismisses the
"contributions" of serious students of human behavior when these
contributions are illusions or misconceptions (which is most
of the time). Your preoccupation with me being the bad guy is
touching but a tad misguided.

Third, Bill Powers was "dismissing", using his rapier wit, the
contributions of serious students of human behavior well before
CSGNet was even a gleem in Gary Cziko's eye. Try reading B:CP,
and LCS I and II, especially the letters in reply to Baum and Reese,
two serious students of human behavior. In particular, read the
reprint of Bill's "Quantitative analysis of purposive systems:
Some spadework at the foundations of scientific psychology" from
Psych Review, 1978. This paper is one long, data filled dismissal
of the contributions of serious students of human behavior.

Finally, the PCT dismissal of the contributions of serious students
of human behavior has everything to do with truth seeking. Perhaps
you haven't gotten this yet but the idea that behavior is the control
of perception is completely antithetical to current ideas about
what behavior is and how it works. PCT shows that serious students
of human behavior have been laboring under an illusion (that behavior
is caused output) since the sciences of the behavior of living systems
were institutionalized over 100 years ago. The only things we dismiss
about the contributions of Martin, Bruce A. and other serious
students of human behavior are the ones that are based on illusion.

Me:

It seems to me that the perception you are controlling is rather
obvious: "the merits of conventional psychophysical research"

Oded:

I think this is the best demonstration of the limits of the test. If
the tester himself controls for NOT(A), where A is some perception in
his own private hierarchy, he will be very likely to interpret any
resistance to his claims as controlling for A by the subject, while
the subject might not have a perception for A at all.

This is nonsense. I can tell what Bill Powers is controlling for,
and it's the same as what I am controlling for. The Tester's
attitude toward the controlled variable has nothing to do with
his ability to determine that it is a controlled variable when
the Test is conducted properly.

Wurst

Rick

···

--
Richard S. Marken Phone or Fax: 310 474-0313
Life Learning Associates e-mail: rmarken@earthlink.net
http://home.earthlink.net/~rmarken

[Oded Maler (980212)-2]

Rick Marken (980212.0750)

Rick:

> It seems to me that the perception you are controlling is rather
> obvious: "the merits of conventional psychophysical research"

Oded:

> I think this is the best demonstration of the limits of the test. If
> the tester himself controls for NOT(A), where A is some perception in
> his own private hierarchy, he will be very likely to interpret any
> resistance to his claims as controlling for A by the subject, while
> the subject might not have a perception for A at all.

  Rick:

This is nonsense. I can tell what Bill Powers is controlling for,
and it's the same as what I am controlling for. The Tester's
attitude toward the controlled variable has nothing to do with
his ability to determine that it is a controlled variable when
the Test is conducted properly.

I am not sure you understood my claim there and instantiated the
variables correctly. Suppose that, hypothetically you do control for
the perception that "conventional research tells us nothing". Whenever
you utter anything in this spirit on the net and detect objection, you
interpret it as if the other is controlling for the opposite
perception, i.e. "conventional research tells us something". But your
opponent might be as well controlling for what he perceives as truth
seeking and just reacting to exaggerated claims you put forward in
order to maintain your favorite perception (whose verbal label for you
is "truth seeking"). I assume that most of what you say on the net is
not just a side-effect of your trying to apply the TEST on students of
human behavior, but rather a bona fida representation of your
"opinions" and a result of trying to control for your perceptions. So
in this context the possibility of labeling the subject's perceptual
variables by the experimenter's own vocabulary is not so remote and is
even more probable that in the case of a neutral setting when the
exprimenter is focused only on the task.

--Oded