DEMO II, COMMENTS - RKC

From Bob Clark (030819:1930 EDT)

Additions to and modifications of the Original "Portable
Demonstrator" were presented Sunday morning, August 1, 1993. The
summary and discussion is in several parts, to be posted as prepared.
IV. is still tentative.

I. PRESENTATION. Observer's View. "DEMO I, PRESNTATN - RKC"

II. COMMENTS. Demonstrator's View. "DEMO II, COMMENTS - RKC"

III. DISCUSSION. Experimenter's View. "DEM III, DSCUSSN - RKC"

IV. TEMPORAL VARIABLES. Various Views. "DEM IV, TEMPRAL VBLS - RKC"

···

----------------------

II. COMMENTS. The Demonstrator's Viewpoint.

Introduction. In presenting this (these) demonstrations, I wanted to
present some extensions and additions to the original Portable
Demonstrator. I think that actual, living, demonstrations are
effective ways to communicate some types of concepts. To show the
differences, it seemed to be a good idea to start with the familiar
sequence of demonstrations, adding the changes at appropriate places
in the sequence.

For most of the new procedures, this was the first time they were
demonstrated. If they are to be repeated, some of the instructions
should be improved.

Throughout these demonstrations, we are trying to demonstrate each of
several controlled variables, together with their (relative) reaction
times. It is also possible to perceive some higher order variables
together with those variables from which they are derived.

Here specific names are suggested for convenience of discussion.
Numerical levels are not assigned at this time.

Letter headings (A, B, C, etc) correspond with part I. PRESENTATION.

A. MUSCLE TENSIONS. Here, this low order demonstration is used to
establish the procedure and the relations between the E and S. It
does, of course, demonstrate what might be called the "single muscle"
response. A combination of several muscles is involved, but a fixed
reference level has been established for the muscle combination as
well as for each individual. The arm is positioned horizontally so
that the muscles must be active, in opposition to gravity. E's push
is the "disturbance" which is quickly opposed and corrected for by
the muscle control system(s). Other perceptual variables that are
active include position detectors (elbow, shoulder, etc) and possible
skin stretching detectors. In this case, the only dominant
perceptual variables are the muscle tension sensors as they oppose
gravity. In general all relevant perceptual variables have fixed
reference levels for maintaining the arm's horizontal position. All
perceptual variables except for the tension sensors are only
moderately affected by E's "push."

B. KINESTHETIC POSITIONS. In accordance with E's instructions, S
establishes a second set of position reference levels for his arm.
On signal, E's downward push, S activates his "new" position
settings. Because the initial settings remain unchanged until S
responds to the signal, the first response, as seen in A, is seen to
occur before the arm can respond to the new settings. This
demonstrates a change from one set of fixed reference settings, the
first position, and a second set of fixed reference settings, the new
position. The time required for changing from one setting to another
is easily perceived. The interaction between two sets of reference
variables (the two positions) is easily perceived.

Since the instructions do not specify the new position, that is
selected by S. The principle difference here is that, in addition to
changing the muscle tension settings, the reference levels for any
operating position sensors (joints, skin, etc) are also changed to
match.

C. VISUAL POSITIONS With his new instructions and other hand, E
provides S with another fixed position. This can only be perceived
by S with his visual system. He may choose to confirm the position
by touch, etc before proceeding with the demonstration. Otherwise, S
faces almost the same situation as before. Namely, on signal, move
to new position as perceived by S. However, in order to display S's
internal position reference levels, E moves his target finger to a
new location at the same moment he gives the change signal. As
observed, S shows the initial muscle response, followed quickly by an
initial swing toward the "new" position. Before the positioning is
complete, S is seen to change his settings to approximate the
modified target position, followed by somewhat slower corrections to
the final position. This demonstrates the action of muscle tension
control systems, combined with position control systems, modified by
visual control systems.

D. TRACKING, WITH VARIATIONS. This group of 5 Demonstrations is
based on the concept of tracking, that is, S matches E's demonstrated
pattern with his own similar pattern.

D1. BASIC TRACKING. This consists of a minimal form of tracking.
After the usual instruction, E provides the reference pattern, here a
fairly smooth one dimensional sine wave. This is a visual input to
S, who shows the initial irregularities observed in C.

D2. VARIATIONS IN SPATIAL VARIABLES. E changes from vertical
movement to horizontal movement, otherwise no change. S exhibits the
same initial irregularities, quickly matching the reference track.
No additional perceptual variables are needed.

D3. VARIATIONS IN TEMPO. After using an assortment of spatial
variables, all using the same sine wave and the same tempo, S
continues to show the initial irregularities as before whenever faced
with a new pattern. At this point, E changes the tempo, without
making any other changes. Essentially the same initial irregularity
is observed. This continues with additional changes in tempo as long
as the tempo is not too fast or too slow.

D4. SQUARE WAVE. After changing all the parameters except wave
form, and finding S's response continues to display the same initial
irregularity, E changes to a symmetrical square wave, at the same
tempo. That is, the top position is held the same length of time
that the bottom position is held, with changes from top to bottom
(and vice versa) as abrupt as E can easily make them. Again S
displays the same (or similar) initial irregularity.

D5. IRREGULAR TIMING. E retains the same top and bottom positions,
but treats them as fixed levels, with abrupt shifts between them.
The delays between shifts are varied irregularly between very short
(forming a "pulse") and very long. The spatial variables remain
fixed (in two sets), while temporal variables are varied.

E. OTHER MUSCLE SYSTEMS. Having demonstrated variations among
spatial and temporal variables, a variation in the set of selected
muscle systems is presented. E changes from his right
hand-forefinger to his left hand-forefinger, continuing the same
movements. S must decide whether to continue with the same hand,
change hands to match E, or stop trying to follow the instructions.
In this case, after showing irregularity of movement while making the
decision, S chose to continue the same hand-forefinger. If the
instructions had been to "do as I do," or similar words instead of
"track my finger," or equivalent, S might have followed E's change of
hands. Hoping that S would follow another change of muscle systems,
E changed from hand movements to head-nodding. Faced with another
decision, S chose to stop trying to follow the movement and reported
the dilemma.

If S had begun following variations in head movement, E was planning
to further shift to movements of feet, beginning a simple dance step
with S.

F. LEADER-FOLLOWER. Since S had ceased to follow E's lead, the
"tracking type" of demonstration was terminated. Instead, a simple
role reversal demonstration was presented. This was first used by
Powers and Clark at the time when they were working together with the
Portable Demonstrator. It consists of the minimal tracking
demonstrations, D1 - D5, with an exchange between "tracker" and
"trackee" on command of a third person. As presented on this
occasion, the command used short forms of the S's names to specify
the "leader." These were stated quickly at irregular time intervals,
and could repeat the same name. Thus the S's had to recognize the
name as well as the occurrence of the "shift command." After
establishing the response patterns, the interval between shifts is
gradually shortened, eventually resulting in confusion on the part of
both S's.

In the process of performing this demonstration, several of the delay
times ("reaction times?") that were observed during the previous
demonstrations were again observable together with additional delays
characteristic of the role-changing situation.

This is the end of "Comments."

-------------------------

"Discussion" and "Temporal Variables" will be posted separately later.

Regards, Bob Clark