# Discover Nothing

**URL:** <http://discourse.iapct.org/t/discover-nothing/3531>\
**Category:** CSG1997\
**Created:** [September 23, 1997, 4:04pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/discover-nothing/3531 "1997-09-23T16:04:16Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 3\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![R\_Marken](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/r/8797f3/32.png) [@R\_Marken](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/R_Marken)\
**Post date:** [September 23, 1997, 4:04pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/discover-nothing/3531/1 "1997-09-23T16:04:16Z")

</div>

[From Rick Marken (970923.0900)]

The October issue of \_Discover\_ magazine is all about "Behavior".  
I bought a copy because I though it might be fun to read through  
it to see if there was any trace of an understanding of behavior  
as a purposeful process of controlling perceptions relative to  
internal references. So far, no luck. But I have learned that the  
new, trendy approach to understanding behavior is in terms of  
genes (combined with influences from the environment) and evolution.  
In the first article I read, the author makes the point that genes  
don't determine behaviors; rather they determine \_tendencies\_ to  
behave in certain ways in the presence of environmental events. So  
the \_new\_ view of human nature is that we behave as we do because  
our genes determine \_tendencies\_ to respond in various ways to  
environmental stimuli. I'm probably biased, but this doesn't seem  
like a huge step beyond S-R psychology to me.

Acts and Results

What is missing from everything I have looked at in the \_Discover\_  
issue so far is any understanding of the fact that when we talk  
about "behavior" we are talking about both \_actions\_ and the  
\_results\_ of those actions; we are talking about both hand  
movements (actions) and the signature on the contract (the result).  
Also missing is the understanding that most consistently produced  
results are produced by different actions every time -- and  
necessarily so or the results (due to disturbances to those results)  
would not repeat. So the same "behavior" (result) is (and must always  
be) produced by different behaviors (actions).

Control

This kind of "behavior" (variables actions producing consistent  
results) can only be accomplished by a system that perceiives the  
state of the result (the signature), compares this percpetion to a  
reference for what that perception \_should be\_, and continuously  
acts (moves the hand) to keep the discrepency between perception  
and reference near zero. The behavior of this system -- the  
relationship between acts, results and disturbances to those  
results -- is called \_control\_. This control system generates  
neither actions or results; rather, it generates a \_perception\_  
(of the intended result) that meets the specifications provided  
by the reference for the perception.

With this understanding of the natujre of behavior, the authors of  
the \_Discover\_ articles on "Behavior" would realize that, if  
anything about behavior is inherited it is reference specifications  
for the states of perceptions -- not specific ways of  
generating actions. They would also undertsand that the apparent  
influence of the environment on responses is not an effect of the  
environment at all; it is the control system acting to protect  
controlled perceptions from environmental disturbance.

Extremism

Reading the \_Discover\_ issue made me realize why a PCT revolution  
is such a remote possibility in the near future. The problems with  
the discussions of behavior in that issue are fundamental. I see  
two ways for control theorists to deal with these problems: 1) try  
to critique the papers carefully and try to explain the flaws in  
detail or 2) explain the fundamental problem (that they are based  
on an incorrect understanding of thenature of behavior itself) and  
reject them out of hand, calling for a new start for behavioral  
science.

The first approach seems like the most reasonable; but it has not  
been very effective because when you get into the details you tend  
to lose the big picture. This is what is happening in the discussion  
with Bruce Abbott; when we get into the details of the problems  
with the EAB view of behavior we (and the people listening) tend to  
miss the big picture -- which is that events in the environment  
don't cause or control behavior (actions or results); rather,  
behavior (actions) control environmantal results (as perceived).

The second approach focuses on the big picture but it can't help  
but come off as extremist. When the big picture is "everything  
you are reading about behavior in the psych journals, textbooks  
and reputable national science magazines (like \_Discover\_) is  
based on a fundamental misconception about the nature of behavior  
and is, thus, wrong or misleading" you can't help sounding like an  
extremsist. Nobody wants to imagine that behavioral science has been  
built, for the last century, on a basic misconception about behavior.  
No one wants to think that nearly all the research done to date is  
virtually useless. People want to take a moderate position on issues;  
they want to believe that the old psychology can't just be all wrong.  
The problem for PCT is that science is not politics; the old  
psychology simply is \_demonstrably\_, fundamentally wrong.

I see no solution to this problem. I don't see how either approach  
to presenting the PCT view of behavior can "work". I think all we  
can do is hope that people of courage and integrity will discover  
PCT, be convinced of its merits based on the \_evidence\_, and start  
studying and dealing with other people as what they are; living  
control systems.

Bruce Abbott (970923.0800 EST) --

> What is your argument, Richard? Is it that one shouldn't accept  
> my position because I am "defending conventional psychology"?

Not at all. We have no more argument about reinforcement. You're  
trying to make points that are irrelevant to the PCT model. We have  
already modelled operant behavior and there is nothing in those  
models that could be called a "reinforcer". All your talk is  
aimed at defending (as I said) a perception of the value of  
conventional psychology. This has nothing to do with whether your  
arguments are correct or not (they're not but you're certainly  
never going to come to your senses so who cares).

My point was simply that your behavior (like mine) is a good  
example (that all those reading CSGNet can see) of control of  
a higher level perception. I'm (hopefully very transparently)  
controlling for some higher level perceptions too; I am controlling  
for a view of behavior as a process of control; for the value of  
the PCT model of behavior; for the fundamental difference between  
PCT and conventional models of behavior. Becuase I am controlling  
for these things we come into frequent conflict because what  
I say to bring these variables to their reference states is a  
disturbance to the variables you are controlling.

I have nothing against you controlling for things like the  
value of conventional psychology. Some of my best friends are  
conventional psychologists. I'm just disappointed because I  
thought you would be a very helpful addition to the PCT  
research team.

Best

Rick

> **···**
>
> --  
> Richard S. Marken Phone or Fax: 310 474-0313  
> Life Learning Associates e-mail: rmarken@earthlink.net  
> [http://home.earthlink.net/~rmarken](http://home.earthlink.net/~rmarken)

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Bruce\_Gregory9](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/b/43a26b/32.png) [@Bruce\_Gregory9](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Bruce_Gregory9)\
**Post date:** [September 23, 1997, 4:41pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/discover-nothing/3531/2 "1997-09-23T16:41:20Z")

</div>

[From Bruce Gregory (970923.1240 EDT)]

Rick Marken (970923.0900)

> The second approach focuses on the big picture but it can't help  
> but come off as extremist. When the big picture is "everything  
> you are reading about behavior in the psych journals, textbooks  
> and reputable national science magazines (like \_Discover\_) is  
> based on a fundamental misconception about the nature of behavior  
> and is, thus, wrong or misleading" you can't help sounding like an  
> extremsist. Nobody wants to imagine that behavioral science has been  
> built, for the last century, on a basic misconception about behavior.  
> No one wants to think that nearly all the research done to date is  
> virtually useless. People want to take a moderate position on issues;  
> they want to believe that the old psychology can't just be all wrong.  
> The problem for PCT is that science is not politics; the old  
> psychology simply is \_demonstrably\_, fundamentally wrong.
> 
> I see no solution to this problem. I don't see how either approach  
> to presenting the PCT view of behavior can "work". I think all we  
> can do is hope that people of courage and integrity will discover  
> PCT, be convinced of its merits based on the \_evidence\_, and start  
> studying and dealing with other people as what they are; living  
> control systems.

There \_is\_ another approach. Consider the geocentric vs.  
heliocentric issue. Rather than arguing that the heliocentric  
model is right and the geocentric model is wrong, we can point  
out that there is a large class of problems (\_not\_ including  
navigation) that are \_much\_ simpler to solve if you adopt the  
perspective of the heliocentric model. This set includes making  
quantitative predictions on the basis of Newton's laws. (I know  
you will argue that the set of problems best addressed by EAB is  
empty, but this is a minor point -- at least one we can avoid  
bringing to the fore.) For example, your tracking results are  
simple to understand in theframework of a PCT model. If someone  
wants to build a quantitative EAB explanation, they are welcome  
to try -- we have other fish to fry. I know you are not keen on  
this approach, but I think it has merits and should be added for  
completeness, if nothing else.

Sancho

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![HANS\_BLOM2](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/h/f17d59/32.png) [@HANS\_BLOM2](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/HANS_BLOM2)\
**Post date:** [September 24, 1997, 3:20pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/discover-nothing/3531/3 "1997-09-24T15:20:26Z")

</div>

[Hans Blom, 970924]

(Rick Marken (970923.0900)) to (Bruce Abbott (970923.0800 EST))

> We have no more argument about reinforcement. You're trying to make  
> points that are irrelevant to the PCT model.

Irrelevant in the sense of orthogonal? Like adding another dimension  
to? If so, I agree. But if so, how can there be a conflict, as in:

> Becuase I am controlling for these things we come into frequent  
> conflict because what I say to bring these variables to their  
> reference states is a disturbance to the variables you are  
> controlling.

Greetings,

Hans
