# E. coli, Is that all

**URL:** <http://discourse.iapct.org/t/e-coli-is-that-all/3708>\
**Category:** CSG1997\
**Created:** [April 14, 1997, 4:56pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/e-coli-is-that-all/3708 "1997-04-14T16:56:07Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 1\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Richard\_Marken1](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/r/ed8c4c/32.png) [@Richard\_Marken1](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Richard_Marken1)\
**Post date:** [April 14, 1997, 4:56pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/e-coli-is-that-all/3708/1 "1997-04-14T16:56:07Z")

</div>

[From Rick Marken (970414.0900 PDT)]

Bruce Abbott (970413.1805 EST)

> in "e. coli-type reorganization," as I understand it, reorganization  
> (the equivalent of tumbling) ceases when there is no error in  
> intrinsic variables.

This is not a necessary feature of the reorganization model of learning.  
The model can work if there is some very low level of reorganization at  
zero intrinsic error or none at all. I believe, however, that there is  
some evidence that reorganization is \_always\_ going on, at a VERY low  
level, even when we can control virtually perfectly (zero intrinsic  
error). For example, both Bill and I have experienced "spontaneous  
reversals" while we were doing  
a tracking task (we suddenly start moving the mouse in the "wrong  
direction" relative to deviations of the controlled variable from the  
reference). We are both skilled trackers and these reversals occur VERY  
rarely. They seem to be the result of the operation of a system (like  
the presumed reorganization system) that occasionally changes a  
parameter of the system randomly to see if there might be a better  
way to control things -- even if control is going very well.

> I can understand how a system attempting to gain control over a  
> given variable could do so by varying the gain (in sign and  
> magnitude) at random until good control resulted...But what if  
> this action is not what is needed? There may be literally  
> thousands of possible error-action relationships from among which  
> to select. Blind trial-and-error would seem to be an extremely  
> poor choice of method for finding a workable solution

I agree. There might be more than blind trial and error involved. But  
this is an empirical question. We need research that looks at the  
reorganization process in detail -- that tracks reorganzation as it is  
occuring. A study that makes a first stab at this is reported by  
Robertson and Glines (I don't have the reference handy; Dick, if you're  
there, could you post it please). They found no evidence of  
"non-randomness" during reorganization but that doesn't mean it's not  
there in some (possibly many) cases.

Mary Powers (970413) to Jeff Vancouver (970408.1700 EST) --

> Whatever point you are making, I don't take too kindly to being  
> misquoted in the process. Your omission completely changes the  
> sense of what I said.

I have to come to Jeff's defense on this one. I'm sure Jeff didn't  
do this on purpose. His misquote looks like a simple case of someone  
desperately trying to reconcile PCT with a cognitive view of behavior.

Best

Rick
