(Gavin Ritz 2010.02.02.21.3NZT)
[From Bruce
Abbott (2010.02.01.1810 EST)]
(Gavin Ritz
01.02.2010.18.06NZT)
Bruce Abbott
(2010.01.31.2210 EST)
(Gavin Ritz 01.02.2010.
13.35NZT) –
BA: I’m
puzzled by your next sentence. I don’t understand what you mean when you
assert that in living things both the structure and process are animate
systems. The neurons making up a neural network are certainly “animate
systems” if by that you mean systems composed of active, living elements
that require energy to function. A neural signal is a process generated by such
an animate system and uses up some of that energy. Is that what you mean? Of
course all the energy expended by a living system is expended by some process.
GR: The concept of structure and process
is an important issue within complexity. For example a roading system has both
a structure (the roading infrastructure) and a process (the vehicle and
transporters on it). Both are inanimate. In a living organism there are for
example a circulatory system with a structure (veins/ arterial networks) and
process (blood flow) but this also has a further level of cells with similar
structure and processes on an even smaller scale. In living entities both
structure and process are animate systems (very dependent) that are informed
energy systems. Whereas in engines this is not the case and neither in roads or
any machine analogy for that matter.
So comparisons are okay but far too reductionist
to be good analogy. Prigogine referred to this as Being and Becoming in far from equilibrium systems
as in living entities, is an important distinction.
GR: So what energy
specifically is involved with producing the reference signal and what about the
premises in B:CP says that there is no energy conservation?
A reference signal in a
living thing can be represented by the rate of firing of a neuron (or of an
assembly of neurons), in which case the energy involved in generating the
impulses comes from the biochemical systems of the neurons involved; that
energy is extracted from chemical bonds of the nutrients during the process of
metabolism. A reference signal could also be implied: if the reference value is
zero, then there doesn’t have to be a neuron present and expending energy
in order to represent that reference: nothing is needed in order to generate
zero impulses per second. In that case no energy is required to implement the
zero reference. Similarly, a mechanical thermostat, set to a particular
temperature by adjusting the distance between its contacts, doesn’t
expend any energy to maintain its reference value, although energy certainly is
expended by the human operator to change that setting.
You see this is where I have a problem
with inanimate systems such as thermostats, being compared to the human nervous
system.
A living being is always metabolizing and neurons
are always firing even when you think nothing is going on. By the very concept
that living matter is informed (DNA and protein relationship). So to speak there is no peace for the
wicked.
An ATP synthase molecule is always driving
the reactions far from equilibrium so the analogies with inanimate systems are
not a great one. In fact wholly unsatisfactory.
There can never be a zero reference signal
by the very nature of a living organism.
As for the conservation
of energy, the energy required to power the control system and its outputs ends
up being dissipated as they do work: in that sense the energy involved in
control is not conserved (it exits the system as waste heat), but with respect
to the system plus its environment, the law of the conservation of energy of
course holds. The energy expended by the system as it does work to control its
controlled variable is still there in the environment, just in a different
form. In other words, for the system and its environment taken as
a whole, energy is conserved.
Okay we agree.
GR: Actually the brain
uses up 25% of the energy of the total energy requirements of the human body
and ATP (the body’s energy source) creates almost 50kg per day, so in
terms of the human nervous system the energy usage is massive quite different
to a cruise control that requires only a small amount of energy.
I’ve heard it said
that the brain uses approximately 25% of the energy requirements of the human
body (I won’t dispute that), but something is wrong with what you said
about ATP in the remainder of the sentence. ATP is the energy source provided
by the cellular mitochondria, but ATP is synthesized in the cell by extracting
the energy in the cellular nutrients as they are oxidized in the process of
metabolism. Those nutrients, originally absorbed during the process of
digestion, ultimately acquired their chemical energy from the sun during plant
photosynthesis.
Another problem with that
portion about ATP is that you apparently have used the wrong units of measure
when you wrote the APT “creates almost 50 kg per
day.” Kilograms is a measure of mass, not energy, as I’m sure you
know. Certainly the cells aren’t making 50 Kg of ATP per day –
that’s over 100 pounds!
Yes of-course mass (kg) and joules
(energy) are not the same thing. Yes it can be even more than 50kg per day. So
the systems are working at impressive rates, some sources say almost one’s
own body weight. My point is this energy conversion is massive and in the brain
massive. We are a massive energy converter. Do a Google search for yourself on
this. I have plenty of notes and lecture notes if you want to see them
All this conversion is done inside each cell
all the time at about 1000 molecules per second by the smallest most efficient
molecular engine (some say 100% efficiency- I cant see how) revolving at unbelievable
speeds hydrolyzing and synthesizing ADP to ATP. Walker and Skou won the Noble Prize for this in 1997 no less.
My point is that, this is in every brain
cell so this is no mean a small amount of energy and conversion. We are an
energy converter par excellence and our models need to reflect this. And specifically
PCT.
Our brains are almost like light bulbs (a
silly analogy actually). The reference signal can under these circumstances never
be zero. In fact I think the reference signals are charged (so to say) all the time.
The human nervous system
does use a lot of energy, but that’s the whole system.
Yes and the nervous system and brain use
up more than 25 percent of that energy.
That system comprises
thousands or perhaps millions of control systems, each of which requires very
little energy for its own operation, far less than the muscles, when they are
active, that these systems may ultimately drive. Even so, I
don’t see your point: even if the energy consumed by the control system
itself were on a par in magnitude with the energy that drives the output being
varied by the control system, the principles of operation are the same.
See my point above.
Regards
Gavin
···