# Leslie

**URL:** <http://discourse.iapct.org/t/leslie/6309>\
**Category:** CSG1999\
**Created:** [January 5, 1999, 8:21pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/leslie/6309 "1999-01-05T20:21:57Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 2\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Bill\_Powers1](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/b/8e7dd6/32.png) [@Bill\_Powers1](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Bill_Powers1)\
**Post date:** [January 5, 1999, 8:21pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/leslie/6309/1 "1999-01-05T20:21:57Z")

</div>

[from Mary Powers 9901.05]

John Appel:

I'm glad you finally got logged on - was there something wrong with the  
instructions I sent to you?

Thanks for posting Leslie's story. I have a few comments which I want to  
make clear are indeed comments, not criticism. They have to do with the  
compatibility (or lack thereof) of your comments and interpretations with  
those of PCT-based therapy, the Method of Levels (MOL)

1) "The CSG may not realize that perceptual control is necessary for sanity."

I think this is well understood, at least implicitly. To be unable to  
control one's perceptions means never being able to bring them to their  
reference states, which means being in a very unhealthy and painful state of  
chronic error.

The main reason for being unable to control perceptions is having opposing  
reference signals demanding that the perception be in two different states  
at once - conflict. I suspect that people who are angry about being  
dependent and unable to do anything about it are unable because they are  
terrified of being autonomous. Everybody starts out in life being  
dependent, and most become autonomous as they mature. Leslie seems to have  
been denied dependency when she needed it and denied autonomy when she was  
ready for that - a nice Catch-22 which left her in conflict.

2) Leslie said "Did my father tell you about their not bringing me up? And  
you answer "Yes, he did tell me".

I'm wondering about this because although I understand you have the  
rationale of supporting her autonomy, you have chosen to do it by lying to  
her. Her father did not tell you anything of the kind. Perhaps you felt he  
"told" you this by implication, but I don't buy it. It's a bit risky to  
"validate" by fudging the truth - what would happen if she found out?

In PCT therapy, MOL, the kind of answer that people are learning to do is  
focussed on going up a level - not confirming a statement at the same level  
(whether or not by a lie). For example: It's important to you for me to  
know that. Or, you want me to have heard that from your father. Or...  
Obviously there is nothing wrong with sticking to the same level until you  
get a good feel for the next level, but the heart and soul of MOL (and we  
hypothesize ALL therapies) is getting up to the next level...and the next...

3) You seem to be quite eclectic in your approach, drawing from  
psychoanalysis (transference) and behavioral approaches (rewards). Maybe  
MOL will make sense to you if I say it seems to me that just when you say  
"our relationship, the father-transference, had begun", is just when she  
shows every evidence of having gone up a level - she says her main fear is  
that when she tells you things you will say there is nothing the matter; she  
says "it's so amazing when you listen to me".

And when you talk of rewarding her, it seems to me that while you might draw  
the analogy of giving a pellet to a deprived and hungry rat, and feel ok  
about it because you were not the depriver in the first place, reward is a  
very controlling concept - just what you want to free her from. You do not  
want her to become dependent on your reward, your good opinion of her; you  
are trying to provide an environment in which her actions truly affect her  
perceptions as she needs them affected. Which is what those of us who do  
MOL try to achieve.

I get the feeling that transference \_is\_ dependence on the rewarder. Isn't  
the end game of this type of therapy to wean the patient from transference,  
from needing that reward from the therapist? Does the idea of not getting  
into a transference situation in the first place sound too weird?

4) "What is perceptual control. Why is it so important?

It is the essence of life to control, to resist forces and events causing  
dissolution and to alter the environment to what one needs and wants it to  
be. The only way to know that there is a discrepancy between what one needs  
and wants and the way things are is to perceive the way things are, compare  
that with the way they should be, and act to reduce the difference. This is  
how a control system works, whether living, electronic, or mechanical. We  
talk of \_perceptual\_ control in living systems to distinguish the process  
from \_control\_ in non-living systems because a) living systems uniquely set  
their own reference signals internally instead of from outside (like a  
thermostat) and b) to forestall the knee-jerk reaction of some people who  
think this is a mechanical, dehumanizing way to talk about people instead of  
the first scientific explanation of the phenomenon of purpose.

Mary P.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![John\_Appel](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/j/7993a0/32.png) [@John\_Appel](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/John_Appel)\
**Post date:** [January 15, 1999, 11:00pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/leslie/6309/2 "1999-01-15T23:00:51Z")

</div>

> From John Appel

Mary Powers

Hello. Here�s a 3rd response to your post re Leslie 1/6/99  
I had not received your response to my 2nd post when I received this  
one.

> You seem to be quite eclectic in your approach, drawing from

psychoanalysis (transference) and behavioral approaches (rewards)\>.

Yes, my approach is both psychoanalytic and behavioral. I came upon my  
notions of control from the perspective of physician treating mental  
disorders. I was amazed and stunned by the power �control� had to  
understand and treat my patients. The theory I formed appears to differ  
somewhat from PCT, at least in certain respects. But both theories are  
about �control.� That is why PCT and MOL. so fascinate me.

\>Maybe MOL will make sense to you if I say it seems to me that just  
when you say  
"our relationship, the father-transference, had begun", is just when she

shows every evidence of having gone up a level - she says her main fear  
is  
that when she tells you things you will say there is nothing the matter;  
she  
says "it's so amazing when you listen to me".\>

I don�t yet understand �levels,� very well.

.\>And when you talk of rewarding her, it seems to me that while you  
might draw  
the analogy of giving a pellet to a deprived and hungry rat, and feel ok

about it because you were not the depriver in the first place, reward is  
a  
very controlling concept - just what you want to free her from. You do  
not  
want her to become dependent on your reward, your good opinion of her;  
you  
are trying to provide an environment in which her actions truly affect  
her  
perceptions as she needs them affected. Which is what those of us who  
do  
MOL try to achieve.\<

I do use the analogy of giving a pellet to a deprived and hungry rat. It  
seems to me Leslie was deprived of dependency when she needed it, though  
In Leslie's� case I would prefer . an apology to a deprived and hungry  
child. It�s difficult for me to think of Leslie as a rat. I do want  
Leslie to become dependent on me, but only until she is ready to become  
independent. I quite agree with you, the end game is not for Leslie to  
be dependent on me, or on anyone else. It is important to be clear about  
the question, dependent for what? No one ever becomes independent on  
others for �love.� However a person can, and should become independent  
on others to make decisions for him. I suggest the definition of an  
adult is-- a person who has a mind of his own and the ability to decide  
for himself what he believes and does.

I am comfortable about Leslie becoming dependent on me for two reasons:  
1, As you say, she, as any person, even an infant, has a powerful drive  
to take control of him, or her self. The infant controls, or tries to  
control its burping and sucking on the nipple. The mother, in her  
anxiety, may try to force the infant to keep sucking, thus the battle  
for control between mother and child is joined. At age 1-1/2 to 2-1/2  
years a toddler normally goes through the �terrible twos,� referred to  
above, and becomes able to choose whether to do, or not to do what his  
mother tells him. He has become autonomous from her control. Similarly  
when he is ready he will go through the �terrible twos� with me, his  
physician, or other therapist. He becomes able to disagree or disobey  
me. 2, The physician rewards the patient's autonomous behavior,  
such as Leslie's decision to ask me a question, which I then rewarded by  
answering. Doing so encouraged her to ask questions as a means of  
getting along with me. Furthermore doing so she showed she was not  
helpless--she had the power to get me to respond . And of course I  
rewarded other behaviors. She could get me to listen when she talked,  
for example. This amazed her because she had never been able to get  
anyone, especially her father or mother, to listen to her. Eliciting  
responses from me she developed a repertoire of behaviors which would  
get her rewards., first from me and then from most people.

> I get the feeling that transference \_is\_ dependence on the rewarder.

Isn't  
the end game of this type of therapy to wean the patient from  
transference,  
from needing that reward from the therapist? Does the idea of not  
getting transference seem weird?\<

I believe transference cannot be avoided. Everyone expects others to  
respond the way his mother, or other care givers did. Thus Leslie was  
�amazed� when I behaved differently than her father. A key element of  
treatment is for the patient to discover the physician responds  
differently than previous care givers. I sense the above might well lend  
itself to MOL.

4) \>\>"What is perceptual control. Why is it so important?\<\<.

I believe I misled the CSG when I posed this question. I was not asking  
for definitions. I had read Bill Powers and many others and formed  
enough understanding of PCT to make me eager to participate in CSG. What  
I was doing when I posed the question was merely giving an account of  
how, I myself, got interested in autonomy--control, namely my experience  
treating psychotic patients who were so out of control, and who got well  
when I found ways to foster their autonomy. That was when I asked  
myself what autonomy was and was why it was so important?

> It is the essence of life to control, to resist forces and events

causing  
dissolution and to alter the environment to what one needs and wants it  
to  
be. The only way to know that there is a discrepancy between what one  
needs  
and wants and the way things are is to perceive the way things are,  
compare  
that with the way they should be, and act to reduce the difference.  
This is  
how a control system works, whether living, electronic, or mechanical.  
We  
talk of \_perceptual\_ control in living systems to distinguish the  
process  
from \_control\_ in non-living systems because a) living systems uniquely  
set  
their own reference signals internally instead of from outside (like a  
thermostat) and b) to forestall the knee-jerk reaction of some people  
who  
think this is a mechanical, dehumanizing way to talk about people  
instead of  
the first scientific explanation of the phenomenon of purpose.\>

My theory certainly agrees that the \<essence of life is to control, to  
resist forces causing dissolution\> I would probably use the term  
�psychosis� for �dissolution.� Your next comment \< to alter the

> leaves me unclear. I guess my theory would say a person is

not able to alter his environment.--he can merely adjust to it. Here  
difference between my theory and PCT may be a semantic, perhaps not.

Thanks for your clarifying statement. It helped me understand MOL a  
little better.

Yours

John Appel.

> **···**
>
> Subject: Leslie and Mary P  
> Date: Jan./11/99  
> From: John Appel  
> To: CSGnet@UIUC.edu.
