# Misc.

**URL:** <http://discourse.iapct.org/t/misc/7012>\
**Category:** CSG1993\
**Created:** [January 30, 1993, 6:18pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/misc/7012 "1993-01-30T18:18:02Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 4\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![William\_T\_Powers2](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/w/c67d28/32.png) [@William\_T\_Powers2](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/William_T_Powers2)\
**Post date:** [January 30, 1993, 6:18pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/misc/7012/1 "1993-01-30T18:18:02Z")

</div>

[From Bill Powers (930130.0830)]

Martin Taylor (930129.1900) --

Petronius Arbiter is talking about what happens when commanders  
are selected by the Peter Principle. Having risen to their level  
of incompetence, they are driven by anxiety which can't be  
alleviated by accomplishment, because they don't know how to  
accomplish what must be done. Therefore they reorganize  
endlessly, passing over bad solutions and good ones alike because  
they can't recognize a good solution when it turns up.

> **···**
>
> ----------------------------------------------------------------  
> Gary Cziko (930130.0430 GMT) --
> 
> Yoru suggestion about instrument disturbances for actions of  
> various speeds is a good one. The main difficulty is that human  
> control systems are too good: it's hard to build an  
> electromechanical system that can apply a known disturbance  
> faster than a human being can correct for it. It's possible, but  
> you need expensive torque motors and very fast servo amplifiers.  
> It's not the sort of thing I can do in my basement computer room.
> 
> > ... I have the intuition that at the very highest speeds  
> > even the final position will not be well-controlled, at least  
> > not without some patch-up correction at the end of the  
> > movement.
> 
> There will be wobbles at the end of a very fast movement, but  
> they'll be on the same time scale that normally applies. That is,  
> if a disturbance occurs within a 40-millisecond jab, it will take  
> 120 to 180 milliseconds to correct 95 - 99 percent of the final  
> position error -- the same as during normal movements.  
> --------------------------------------------------------------  
> A thought about lexicons and other side-issues of PCT.
> 
> There seems to be a difference in the way scientists approach  
> studies of natural phenomena that parallels the differences  
> between some organized religions. In one religion it is claimed  
> that God's Truth can reach the common person, but only through  
> the intercession of qualified and approved theologians. In  
> another, it is claimed that each person has an individual contact  
> with God that requires no human intermediaries, no ritual, no  
> ceremony.
> 
> It seems to me that this same dispute occurs in science. One  
> group works on the basis that the great minds of the past have  
> revealed the basic working of nature to the less-inspired, so  
> that for the common scientist to learn Truth, there must be a  
> devoted study of the wisdom of the past, and observance of the  
> rituals prescribed by the most gifted of scientists. But another  
> group -- much smaller, I fear -- believes that any individual can  
> explore nature directly, without any intermediary and without the  
> need for observing customary rituals.
> 
> This distinction is particularly important in studies of human  
> nature. The first group decided some time ago that subjective  
> observations of human nature are untrustworthy and misleading, so  
> that to discover his or her own workings, an individual must  
> learn the methods of objective science and study the findings  
> about human behavior that our illustrious forebears have  
> established. But the second group, of which I am obviously a  
> member, believes that truths about human nature are available to  
> anyone who takes the trouble to ask the right questions and  
> observe himself/herself closely and with honesty.
> 
> Ed Ford, whatever his theological leanings, has shown himself to  
> be a scientist of the second kind. He has shown that anyone,  
> given a couple of rubber bands and a willing partner or two, can  
> rediscover fundamental phenomena of control quite independently  
> of what anyone else says they are, without mathematical rituals,  
> and without asking any authority whether he has it right. The  
> question is put directly to nature, and nature, acting as it  
> must, demonstrates the answer.
> 
> We may, of course, dispute within and among ourselves as to what  
> the answer signifies, because significance gets us into  
> speculation about what we haven't observed. But each of us has a  
> working brain, of which we see far more than anyone else can see  
> even if we can't see it all. Each of us lives in a private world  
> of experience of which no one else knows anything. Each person,  
> alone, can explore this laboratory and learn at least something  
> about how its apparatus works. How strange to think that one  
> might decide to ignore this laboratory, and judge human nature  
> only on the basis of what certain others, working in their own  
> private laboratories somewhere else and long ago, have said about  
> it.  
> ---------------------------------------------------------------  
> Best to all,
> 
> Bill P.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Hortideas\_Publishin1](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/h/f6c823/32.png) [@Hortideas\_Publishin1](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Hortideas_Publishin1)\
**Post date:** [April 19, 1993, 11:08am UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/misc/7012/2 "1993-04-19T11:08:00Z")

</div>

> From Greg Williams (930419)

Ed Ford has been disconnected involuntarily from the net (at his end)  
and is looking for a different way to connect. He says he'll probably  
be back on in a week or so, maybe via MCI Mail (isn't it interesting  
that some of us are willing to pay money to get into arguments?). My  
schedule and Ed's should allow us to mail the Spring issue of CLOSED  
LOOP (on portable PCT demos) sometime during the first week in May.

> **···**
>
> -----
> 
> > Bill Powers (930417.1530)
> 
> > In the last post to you, I applied a number of disturbances,  
> > assuming that your goal was to maintain that the Test had not met  
> > your requirements.  
> > ...  
> > In today's post, you clearly rejected every such claim, giving  
> > your reasons for the rejection and in general trying to correct  
> > the false impression of your position that I was giving.
> 
> > So I deduce that there is some controlled perception here, which  
> > was disturbed by my assertions, your statements today being  
> > designed to protect correct some effect of that disturbance. I  
> > would guess that this reference perception is the perception that  
> > the challenge has not been met.
> 
> You have convincingly (to me) deduced my reference perception. In my  
> opinion, you applied The Test in a manner such that you sufficiently  
> (to my thinking -- others might disagree) narrowed the possibilities  
> of what my reference perception might be in this case. So you are 1  
> for 2, still having not convinced me in your earlier efforts with  
> regard to a different reference perception. (Of course, you might  
> consider the score premature, if you still want to keep trying on that  
> earlier work.)
> 
> > If I wanted to find out why you are controlling the variable in  
> > question here, I would begin applying disturbances to the idea  
> > that subjective impressions are not sufficient evidence for a  
> > scientific test. I might just insist that they are quite  
> > sufficient, or even more directly, intimate that YOU think they  
> > are quite sufficient. Having established, more or less, that this  
> > opinion \_is\_ a reference level, perhaps I would try to go still  
> > more more level higher, trying to see what would be disturbed if  
> > this opinion were to change. But by that time we could hardly do  
> > without a continuous face-to-face interchange -- and an audience  
> > might not be appropriate.
> 
> I suspect that you COULD do this. If you want to take the next flight  
> to Kentucky, I'll be happy to give it a try -- or do you think that  
> isn't practical?
> 
> > And perhaps now you might be willing to concede that it's not as  
> > hard as it seems.
> 
> "Hard," of course, is in the eye of the beholder. It appears to me  
> that the difficulty of successfully (that is, with respect to  
> standards accepted by interested scientists) Testing for reference  
> levels can vary enormously, depending on the inclinations of the  
> Testee, the cleverness of the Tester, the resources of the Testee,  
> etc. To judge by our challenge experiences to date, I'd say that  
> sometimes applying The Test successfully appears quite easy and  
> sometimes it appears quite difficult. Perhaps YOU might be willing to  
> concede that it's not always as easy as you thought previously.
> 
> -----
> 
> > Tom Bourbon [939416.1649 CDT]
> 
> > Greg, as you alrady knew, and as Clark confirmed, there are others on  
> > the net far more well versed in the sociological literature than I,  
> > but I was happy to see that Clark's informed post meshed with my  
> > impressions of the literature. I, too, was ignorant of Little's work,  
> > but the passages you quoted were inline with the general impression  
> > that I described in my earlier post: most people who write about  
> > inner direction write of the direction of ACTIONS, not of PERCEPTIONS.  
> > I will not try, in the few minutes I have left on the net this  
> > afternoon, to point out all of the reasons I believe Little is in that  
> > group; I believe yuor opening quotation from him is enough. People  
> > are "...AGENTS whose actions are directed by their beliefs, goals,  
> > meanings, values, prohibitions, and scruples." QED (in the sense in  
> > which QED is used outside of physics)
> 
> > In a manner of speaking (an everyday manner), that sounds true. As a  
> > characterization of a behaving PCT control system, it is not true.  
> > The \*perceived consequences\* of the actions of a PCT system are  
> > "directed by" the systems reference signals (aka, in everyday  
> > language, beliefs, goals ... and scruples"); its actions are not. All  
> > else in the passages from Little is subject to the consequences of  
> > this initial difference between his ideas and PCT. (This is not to  
> > belittle Little -- just to say that the passages you quote from him  
> > are in agreement with my original post.)
> 
> I read the Little quotes with a different interpretation: that RCTers  
> (like PCTers) say that WHATEVER means (outputs) necessary to result in  
> perceived results (outcomes) matching desired ends (goals), given the  
> environmental context (disturbances) will be generated by rational  
> humans (humans with normally functioning control systems). In  
> particular, to me it sounds like he is saying that the RCTers claim  
> that goals, not outputs, are shared in cooperative social endeavors. I  
> guess the question now is which interpretation is more appropriate to  
> what RCTers actually say (as I pointed out in an earlier post, Little  
> isn't an RCTer himself). Clark, what do you think? I assume you've  
> read some writings by RCTers and their precursors. Do they emphasize  
> output specification or goal matching?
> 
> -----
> 
> > Rick Marken (930418.1000)
> 
> > > Rick, do you believe that all (or practically all) perceptual signals
> > 
> > involved in control loops are accessible (perhaps with practice or  
> > other special procedures) to awareness?
> 
> > Yes. I think what you mean is something like "if a tester discovers that  
> > I am controlling p, can I become aware of p".
> 
> > What is the evidence?
> 
> > None, really. Just based on my assumption that all perceptual  
> > signals in the model, controlled or not, can become the objects  
> > of awareness. It would be difficult to show that this is NOT the  
> > case, by the way. How could I ever be made aware of the fact that  
> > I am controlling perceptions that I cannot be made aware of?
> 
> Seeing the results of lab test showing control of concentration of  
> some bodily chemical (say, blood glucose) in the face of a  
> "challenge" (say, 10 Twinkies) might make you aware of biochemical  
> control loops which involve "unconscious" perceptions resulting from  
> chemosensors (or how about one particular chemosensor?), but those  
> perceptions might not be able to ever be perceived "consciously." A  
> related issue is consciousness of perception in "lower" animals. I'm  
> not claiming that I have much evidence on these issues, but I have  
> read that signals (a low rate of action potential generation) from a  
> single pressure receptor in the skin ARE accessible to a person's  
> consciousness. It WOULD be interesting to somehow learn to "feel"  
> fluctuations in local concentrations of particular biochemicals. I  
> suspect that there would be practical difficulties in doing this in at  
> least some cases.
> 
> As ever,
> 
> Greg

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Ed\_Ford1](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/e/a3d4f5/32.png) [@Ed\_Ford1](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Ed_Ford1)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 1992, 6:22pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/misc/7012/3 "1992-06-14T18:22:56Z")

</div>

from Ed Ford (920614:11:30)

Gary Cziko -

&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Would you please send me your INTRODUCTION TO THE CONTROL SYSTEMS  
GROUP NETWORK (CSGnet). Somehow, I lost part of it and could use it as  
a handout when people show an interest in the CSG or in PCT. Thanks.

Martin -

&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Thanks for the input.

Ed Ford ATEDF@ASUVM.INRE.ASU.EDU  
10209 N. 56th St., Scottsdale, Arizona 85253 Ph.602 991-4860

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Judd\_Joel](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/j/b9bd4f/32.png) [@Judd\_Joel](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Judd_Joel)\
**Post date:** [October 5, 1995, 4:03pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/misc/7012/4 "1995-10-05T16:03:00Z")

</div>

[from Joel Judd 951005.0830 CST]

Just felt like having a virtual conversation:

Brian D. (951004):

> But this "feminine" part of the  
> male is nothing less than the foundation of his psyche and self  
> system, and it cannot be eradicated. It therefore continually  
> impinges on his self perception, generating chronic conflict with  
> his socially programmed reference perception for "not feminine."  
> What I said is that this \_conflict\_ between reference perception  
> and perception, not the reference perception by itself, constitutes  
> "male gender insecurity." Meanwhile, it is no wonder that males  
> periodically go berserk.

Can I ask how this phenomena is "known"? Personally, I don't think I go  
berserk periodically, but perhaps I do it in subtle ways 😉 On the other  
hand, maybe this conflict develops early. My six year-old stood and  
screamed at the top of his lungs in a parking lot last night as my wife and  
I moved farther away. He didn't want to go to the store, he didn't want to  
stay home; he didn't want to talk, he didn't want to be left alone...I'm  
going to have a talk with my wife.

> **···**
>
> +\*+\*+\*+\*+\*+\*+\*+\*+\*+\*  
> Rick M. (951004)
> 
> When you get back from Catalina again--  
> Aren't the conditions of the jury verdict perfect PCT fodder? Remember,  
> "we" saw and heard anything and just about everything related to the trial  
> and the evidence, things the jury supposedly never saw or heard. In  
> addition, they only had to have a "reasonable doubt." Furthermore, they've  
> been at this for over a year. Given just the things they saw and heard, did  
> they have enough information to eliminate reasonable doubt?
> 
> I'm waiting to see if Murder One digs into juror psychology.  
> +\*+\*+\*+\*+\*+\*+\*+\*+\*+\*+\*  
> Bruce A. (or anyone)
> 
> I noticed you applied the K coefficient to multiple regression as well as  
> simple r. Is the interpretation of K's application to the former as  
> straightforward as to the latter? Most published correlative results in the  
> literature I read almost always involve multiple factors (what with more  
> powerful computing resources and all); most ANOVA-type analyses are often  
> MANOVA now, and so on. It gets harder to lead people back to the premises  
> of these studies, because the complexity of the research design can be  
> persuasive.
> 
> ANYONE JOINING THE STATISTIC THREAD FOR THE FIRST TIME:
> 
> A repeated reference to some candid discussion of statistical significance  
> testing:
> 
> Special Issue of the \_Journal of Experimental Education\_, 61(4).
> 
> Sample quote:  
> &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;"Reports of tests of statistical significance that are not based on  
> randomized samples  
> &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;should not be published."
> 
> Joel Judd  
> jjudd@mail.dese.state.mo.us
