# modeling help?

**URL:** <http://discourse.iapct.org/t/modeling-help/14282>\
**Category:** CSG1999\
**Created:** [August 10, 1999, 7:18pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/modeling-help/14282 "1999-08-10T19:18:19Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 2\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Norman\_T\_Hovda1](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/n/bb73d2/32.png) [@Norman\_T\_Hovda1](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Norman_T_Hovda1)\
**Post date:** [August 10, 1999, 7:18pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/modeling-help/14282/1 "1999-08-10T19:18:19Z")

</div>

[From Norman Hovda (990810.12:15 MST]

(I'm willing to carry on with the above convention, but I'm also curious as  
to why since the header of every e-mail msg contains similar info?)

On to help with modeling... assuming this is appropriate to this forum...  
if not just send me on my way.

In examining PCT web info and demos I found a model that may  
sufficiently correspond with my observations so as to be used to  
simulate and/or monitor in real time organized exchanges in free  
markets, i.e., the Dow Jones Industrial Averages (DJIA) and "An  
experiment with a simple method for controlling an inverted pendulum"  
by Bill Powers, "Journal on Perceptual Control theory, Vol 1, No 1,  
1999, or at the very least a place to begin.

As best I call tell, given my rudimentary understanding of PCT, certain  
modifications to Bill's model will be required but I'm in way over my head  
as regarding the mathematical / engineering details described in the 10  
page Journal article. Therefore I will rely on my mathematician /  
programer to follow any specific suggestions any of you may offer.  
OTOH, for this layman, I will appreciate efforts to KISS. \<g\>

Here's my situation as a PCT newbee. I'm looking to see how PCT may  
assist with stock market analysis, i.e., the DJIA. I observe DJIA pattern  
regularity that suggests a PC system controlling for balance over time.

In the above Inverted Pendulum demo the user/mouse controls the  
reference signal (bob) and "... the cart immediately moves under the bob  
and the bob quickly comes into balance." IMO the DJIA data, when  
arranged according to specific parameters, implies a bob type reference  
signal (price 10745 shown in table illustration at following URL) which I  
am able to define and track. Note the Mode of the letters distribution at  
table's far right column.

[http://www.cbot.com/mplex/quotes/ldbbs/ldbs-dj1.htm](http://www.cbot.com/mplex/quotes/ldbbs/ldbs-dj1.htm)

The data offer information regarding price as a messenger about a  
perceived cart or value area range. Obviously price location above or  
below the fair \*value area\* offers defined trading opportunities.

(The "value area" = Bill's "cart" and is represented in the gifs mentioned  
below by a solid vertical line adjacent to the left side of each price  
distribution. The "bob" is the mode of the price distribution)

I've developed sftwr producing a continuous stream of actual measured  
bobs and carts data, minute by minute, derived from variety of timeframe  
sample sizes of DJIA tick data. All timeframe bobs determine respective  
timeframe cart location by design but I observe as well (perhaps similar  
to the Counter Control mentioned 990805 & 6 by Rick and Bruce) that,  
at times, larger timeframe carts' balance is controlled for a shorter  
timeframe bob and likewise there are occasions when shorter timeframe  
carts' balance is controlled for a larger timeframe bob. However, the  
complex interplay of the various timeframe bobs make it difficult to  
determine \*which\* timeframe bob is dominating, i.e., for which bob is  
the market gaining and/or maintaining the most effective control.

[http://www.primenet.com/~nth/DDD1.gif](http://www.primenet.com/~nth/DDD1.gif)

The above gif shows all three timeframe carts and bobs lined up.

[http://www.primenet.com/~nth/DDD2.gif](http://www.primenet.com/~nth/DDD2.gif)

This second gif shows the same three timeframes as DDD1.gif, but later  
in the day, where the left and smallest timeframe cart and bob are  
dominating, or if PCT can assist with this analysis, \*possibly\*  
demonstrating the most effective control.

Now the question needing answer is, is it more likely that the smaller  
cart and bob timeframe maintain control so that the larger timeframe will  
reorganize / balance at lower prices or will the larger timeframe cart and  
bod regain control thus eventually bringing the smaller timeframe cart  
and bob into alignment with its larger self?

If the above is seen to be at all in the PCT ball park, what modeling  
suggestions would anyone care to offer which

1. may help determine which bob, as a reference signals from a variety  
of timeframe sample sizes, is the most effective real time controller?

and/or

2. to create a real time index that would represent an implied reference  
signal bob based upon the aggregate of actual bobs and carts data from  
a variety of timeframe sample sizes.

TIA,

nth

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Marc\_Abrams2](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/m/47e85d/32.png) [@Marc\_Abrams2](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Marc_Abrams2)\
**Post date:** [August 11, 1999, 2:23am UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/modeling-help/14282/2 "1999-08-11T02:23:51Z")

</div>

from [Marc Abrams (990810.2210)]

> [From Norman Hovda (990810.12:15 MST]
> 
> (I'm willing to carry on with the above convention, but I'm also curious

as

> to why since the header of every e-mail msg contains similar info?)

It's a nice concise way of referring to a post. A second reason is that  
these posts are archived and that number is part the post's ID#. The last  
reason is tradition. In the early days of CSG, Posts came in with all sorts  
of headers and different dates and times on them. ( btw, that is still true  
for people who get the digest )

> On to help with modeling... assuming this is appropriate to this forum...  
> if not just send me on my way.

This is a forum that utilizes modeling. But it is not a forum about modeling

The rest of the post is out of my league. 🙂

Marc
