Models (from Mary)

[from Mary Powers 950903]

Robert Radford 950902:

As competition is inherent in the evolutionary process by which
we arrived at humanity...

This is a rather old-fashioned/19th century/social
Darwinism/nature-red-in-tooth-and-claw remark. To my mind it
invalidates the rest of your comment. Certainly competition
exists, but built into evolution? What's "built into evolution"
is the fact that what are evolving are control systems, which
interact with one another sometimes as competitors, and sometimes
- probably much more often - cooperatively.

Companies compete because laws require it; I think their execs
would much rather go the route of mergers, monopolies, cartels,
price-fixing arrangements, etc. What laws we have to prevent
this are supposed to protect people from the consequences of
corporate cooperation - since corporations, as legal "persons",
are sociopathic immortals, and not to be trusted. But over all,
for people as well as "persons", you-scratch-my-back-I'll-
scratch-yours is usually preferred to mortal combat.

Bruce Abbott, etc.:

To me, the problem with the physicists' fish school model, and
other models from physics and math (strange attractors and so on)
is that the aim appears to be to explain behavior without
reference to internal purpose - sharing the behaviorist goal and
assuming that attaining it is the proper goal for the life,
behavioral, and social sciences. It's not just this one example
that set Tom's teeth on edge, it's a prevailing attitude that
PCTers have encountered a number of times.

What really puzzles me is that here is PCT, a model developed in
engineering physics, that can and is realized in mechanical.
electronic, and computer-simulated forms (as well as in
organizations of soft, squishy components); that requires far
less computing power to produce more realistic behavior, and that
takes up and resolves the century-old issue of consistent results
being produced by varying means - and apparently as far as
physics is concerned, control systems don't count! I think these
theoretical types are so far removed from technical applications
that they simply don't know about control systems, or consider
them too practical and mundane to be worth investigating.

Mary P.

(Robert Radford 9509041750)

In article <01HUU6QG3IVMFKMA5Z@FORTLEWIS.EDU>, "William T. Powers"

Certainly competition exists, but built into evolution? What's "built

into evolution"

is the fact that what are evolving are control systems, which
interact with one another sometimes as competitors, and sometimes
- probably much more often - cooperatively.

Companies compete because laws require it; I think their execs
would much rather go the route of mergers, monopolies, cartels,
price-fixing arrangements, etc.

What's built in to evolution is the notion that when any self-replicating
population runs into limited resources, those most suited for that
environment are those most likely to reproduce and those least suited anr
those least likely to reproduce. We call the pressure competition because
there are winners and losers in the reproduction game i.e. the game of
life. The unit of reproduction may be the gene (a chicken is an egg's
method of reproducing). There does not seem to be any current support for
the belief that the unit is the individual (or, as you say, the control
system) although obviously improved control systems would be a good method
for a gene to pursue and to that extent, control systems may evolve.

The point is that there has to be competition by definition any time there
are limits. While companies may rather go the route of monopolies, etc.,
they must also face the problem of the Prisoners Dilemma in that they each
want the others to co-operate but they will have an advantage if they
betray the others. Somehow the notion that it is easy or even common for
monopolies or cartels to form seems non-obvious as it requires there be
only a few players and some social glue that will prevent betrayal.

In the case of the current discussion, my point was that if a company
adopted PCT and, if PCT helped that company, other companies would be
compelled to adopt it or vanish from the scene unless they had
compensatory advances. When all the companies had adopted PCT, then the
selection pressure would be on some other difference. That, in itself, is
not an argument that the companies should not adopt PCT as the companies
that did not adopt it would not survive.

My point was in answer to your criticism that if one company adopted it,
all would so there was no point in one company commencing the process.

[From Tom Bourbon (950905.1330)]

(Robert Radford 9509041750)

In reply to Mary Powers, you wrote:

What's built in to evolution is the notion that when any self-replicating
population runs into limited resources, those most suited for that
environment are those most likely to reproduce and those least suited anr
those least likely to reproduce. We call the pressure competition because
there are winners and losers in the reproduction game i.e. the game of
life. The unit of reproduction may be the gene (a chicken is an egg's
method of reproducing). There does not seem to be any current support for
the belief that the unit is the individual (or, as you say, the control
system) although obviously improved control systems would be a good method
for a gene to pursue and to that extent, control systems may evolve.

You seem to draw a distinction between a "gene" and a "control system."
Mary doesn't. (Nor do many other PCT modelers and theorists.) You might
find it interesting were you to read her post again, keeping in mind the
fact that action at the level of genes might be conceived of as a process
of perceptual control.

Later,

Tom