PCT applied to teaching

[From Bruce Abbott (970319.1510 EST)]

Rick Marken (970319.0800) --

I had hoped that those who got involved in the application of PCT to
practical situations would do the hard work of developing the methods
that could be used to access control in those situations. I thought we
might see some catalogs of the kinds of possible controlled variables
to test for in educational or clinical situations of various sorts. I
thought we would see descriptions of clever techniques for asking questions
or posing problems that would reveal the variables under control.

As the teacher is herself a perceptual control system, perhaps the place to
start is for the teacher to identify her own controlled variables as they
relate to the education of her students. Does she want to perceive that her
students like her? That they perform well on tests? That they demonstrate
an understanding of the material that goes beyond simply echoing what they
have studied? That they give her high ratings on student evaluations? All
the above?

The next questions then become, are these goals realistic? Do they
conflict? If so, which should be pursued at the expense of which? Or is
there a way to change the situation so that they do not conflict? What
means do I have at my disposal for evaluating the current states of the
relevant variables? (Without adequate feedback, control becomes difficult
or impossible.) When error is detected, what actions will tend to bring
about correction?

Perceptual control theory says that problems in maintaining control over
important CVs should eventually lead to reorganization of the system. If
the teacher's actions do not succeed in affecting the CV in the required
negative feedback (error correcting) fashion, other methods will presumably
be tried until adequate control is established. Actions that disturb the
student's CVs may produce a variety actions on the part of the student,
including such things as learning the material by rote, skipping or dropping
class, developing an understanding of principles, or complaining about the
difficulty of the tests. Part of the art of good teaching, it seems to me,
is providing an atmosphere in which (if possible) the student comes to view
the teacher's goals for her as her own goals (removing conflict) or at least
that working toward those goals is the best way to control her own
class-related CVs (e.g., getting a good grade, or the teacher's approval).
A student who is "trying" but still fails to grasp the material may soon
give up, having failed to achieve control; reorganization (pursuing
alternative goals) may then lead to further actions that are incompatible
with academic success, such as skipping class, failing to do homework, or
being disruptive in the classroom.

I can see that I'm free-associating here; sorry if I've skipped around a
bit. But my main point is that assessing the current CVs of the students
may be only a relatively small part of a PCT-aware mode of teaching.
Successful teaching is a goal of the _teacher_; the system controling that
variable sets references for other lower-level perceptions concerning
student performance and understanding. This implies that the teacher must
have good means of monitoring those perceptions and a knowledge of
techniques or approaches that generally work in the sense of correcting
these errors. Where teachers often fail is in (a) not seeking out and
receiving accurate information on the states of those CVs in a timely
fashion (e.g., not realizing that students aren't following your discussion,
or are not aware of which points are important and which are ancillary), and
(b) not having the knowledge/skills required to identify and correct known
problems when they arise (ineffective actions).

Although in some problem cases achieving success may require a more detailed
knowledge of the variables those particular students are controlling
(particularly if they are at variance with success as defined by the
teacher), I rather strongly suspect that general approaches exist that will
be effective with the majority of students. But what are these
generally-successful approaches? What CVs do they involve, at what levels,
and what actions? Answering these questions, it seems to me, is where a bit
of applied PCT-inspired research would have a positive impact on teaching
success.

Some people are phenomenal teachers in the classroom. What variables do
_they_ control, and how?

Regards,

Bruce

[From Bruce Gregory (970319.1645)]

Bruce Abbott (970319.1510 EST)]

Where teachers often fail is in (a) not seeking out and
receiving accurate information on the states of those CVs in a timely
fashion (e.g., not realizing that students aren't following your discussion,
or are not aware of which points are important and which are ancillary)

The notion that one learns anything by "following discussions"
needs to be carefully examined.

Some people are phenomenal teachers in the classroom. What variables do
_they_ control, and how?

The word "phenomenal" is interesting. I have lots of evidence
that some teachers are very popular. I have much less evidence
that more that a handful of teachers are effective -- that
students come out of their classes knowing a great deal more
than they went in knowing. Most studies show little connection
between perceived effectiveness and knowledge gain.

Bruce Gregory