# SIMCON; categories

**URL:** <http://discourse.iapct.org/t/simcon-categories/10154>\
**Category:** CSG1997\
**Created:** [January 20, 1997, 4:46pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/simcon-categories/10154 "1997-01-20T16:46:45Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 2\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Martin\_Taylor3](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/m/7ea924/32.png) [@Martin\_Taylor3](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Martin_Taylor3)\
**Post date:** [January 20, 1997, 4:46pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/simcon-categories/10154/1 "1997-01-20T16:46:45Z")

</div>

[Martin Taylor 970120 11:10]

> Bill Powers (970117.1420 MST)]
> 
> General note:
> 
> Wolfgang Zocher has reminded me of his analog-computer-on-a-digital-  
> computer, Simcon, which is now in version 5.2. It doesn't have the graphical  
> layout capability of Stella, but it works great and it doesn't cost hundreds  
> of dollars (it's free). Furthermore, computing setups are ASCII files that  
> can be sent directly over the net. Anyone can run the simulations without  
> having to know how to program them. I have the new postscript version of the  
> manual, and have asked Wolfgang to send me the latest source code (C) and  
> runnable code for PCs. When I get it all together and checked out, I'll post  
> it on my FTP page. Watch for the announcement.

Well, since I can't run any of the SIMCON stuff, I am trying to learn Java  
by rewriting SIMCON in Java. Wolfgang has been kind enough to send me the 5.2  
source, and I have edited the manual into an HTML version with internal  
cross-links that make it (a little) easier to look up points while one  
is working through the examples. (Wolfgang sent me an HTML version without  
the cross-links). I've sent the revised version to Wolfgang (last night).  
By the way, for the person who wanted his e-mail address, it's:  
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;zzzo@apollo.han.de

One point: my revised manual also notes the computational artifact (found  
by Bill P. and me some years ago) involved in the calculation of "optimum  
gain" for the "Simple Control System" program, and suggests as an exercise  
for the reader that they rewrite the program to simulate the same analogue  
network with values of the compute iteration cycle (dt) reduced by a factor  
of ten. This augments the discussion of computational artifacts later in the  
manual.

Such computational artifacts are an ever-present hazard when simulating  
analogue machines in discrete time, and as Bill P has so often said, the  
only sure(-ish) way of avoiding them is to try the same simulation at  
two quite different iteration speeds. I felt that the SIMCON manual ought  
to point this out. My own ad-hoc approach is to ensure that no big changes  
to a signal value or any of its derivatives happen, and that no signal  
influences its own value, in less than two (and preferably considerably  
more) compute iteration cycles.

If I ever learn enough Java to be able to produce a full (or even partial)  
version of SIMCON, of course I'll post it, either on the CSG Web site  
or on my own (\<[http://www.servtech.com/public/mmt&gt;\](http://www.servtech.com/public/mmt&gt;%5C)). It probably won't  
use any of Wolfgang's source code, and will run a lot slower than his  
unless it is run on a machine with a Java "Just In Time" (JIT) compiler.  
But it will accept any legal SIMCON program--or at least that's a design  
objective.

The point of all this is to make the discussions that can be elucidated  
by running SIMCON programs available to everyone, not just those with PCs.  
I have more ambitious hopes, but SIMCON is quite ambitious enough for now:-)

By the way, Wolfgang told me that the 5.2 version runs only on Unix systems,  
and that nobody had volunteered to port it to PCs. Has somebody now offered  
to do that port? He says the code has "defines" for PCs, though. Or maybe  
I misinterpreted him. I haven't looked through his code yet.

> **···**
>
> -----------------  
> On the other matter:
> 
> > I think what's happened is that I have reached my reference level for  
> > speculating about higher levels of organization without data, and want to  
> > get back to what is the main point for me: building the PCT model step by step.
> 
> That's a very reasonable position. But it doesn't preclude you from answering  
> the question I asked twice, which can be boiled down to:
> 
> What do you think is the difference between our two views of category  
> processing, other than that I permit and you prohibit inputs to category  
> perceptual functions from the higher levels of the hierarchy?
> 
> You were quite clear that there are indeed "deep and fundamental" differences,  
> by which I assume you meant that the differences were important enough to  
> be mentioned, at least, and probably important enough to be discussed. But  
> you never said what these difference are. Even if you would prefer to  
> work only on building the lower levels, I think it a bit unfair of you to  
> leave me hanging with the assertion that I am making important differences  
> to the HPCT model on which everyone else is working, without telling me  
> what those differences are.
> 
> A second question that follows is:
> 
> Is the difference between permitting and prohibiting category inputs from  
> higher levels important or trivial? If it's important, why?
> 
> (These questions are open to everyone to answer, of course).
> 
> Martin

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Bill\_Powers1](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/b/8e7dd6/32.png) [@Bill\_Powers1](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Bill_Powers1)\
**Post date:** [January 20, 1997, 6:45pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/simcon-categories/10154/2 "1997-01-20T18:45:25Z")

</div>

[From Bill Powers (970120.1100 MST)]

Martin Taylor 970120 11:10]--

> What do you think is the difference between our two views of category  
> processing, other than that I permit and you prohibit inputs to category  
> perceptual functions from the higher levels of the hierarchy?

...  
I think it a bit unfair of you to

> leave me hanging with the assertion that I am making important differences  
> to the HPCT model on which everyone else is working, without telling me  
> what those differences are.

Your saying that category perceptions exist at every level implies to me  
that there are category perceivers in, say, the brainstem, and that in  
animals which lack higher-level systems, there are still category  
perceptions. This is a major departure from HPCT. Your proposal also leaves  
some important questions dangling: for example, how could you form a  
category whose elements come from two different lower levels of perception?  
Another: is, say, a relationship category derived from two  
configuration-category signals in a way parallel to the analog relations in  
the analog hierarchy? In other words, is there a categorical perceptual  
hierarchy similar to the analog perceptual hierarchy, similar in the way  
higher-order perceptual signals are derived from lower-order ones? Is there  
a categorical control hierarchy, in which categorical error signals are  
transformed into lower-order catgorical reference signals? Is there a  
categorical output function at the lowest level which transforms a category  
error into a categorical muscle tension?

> A second question that follows is:
> 
> Is the difference between permitting and prohibiting category inputs from  
> higher levels important or trivial? If it's important, why?

As to categories of higher-level perceptions, this has been discussed from  
time to time. The consensus was that no, there are probably not such  
perceptual categories. What we categorize are \_names\_ of higher-level  
perceptions (such as names of programs and names of principles). Names and  
symbols are lower-level perceptions which we attach (somehow) to experiences  
in which (from a higher level) we recognize examples of higher perceptions.  
Once having done so, we can then start again and build up relationships,  
sequences, and categories \_of symbols\_, and so on. Each time we do this, we  
move to another level of verbal or mathematical abstraction, but not another  
level of perception. We simply get farther from the original experiences,  
using the same basic mental operations but applying them to the lower-level  
perceptions we use as symbols instead of directly to nonsymbolic experiences.

Of course I don't KNOW any of that. All that is just supposition, a  
possibility, a speculation. There is no present way to arrive at an answer  
concerning such questions; all we can do is say "Yes, but if that's so, then  
what about \_this\_?," enjoying ourselves over our sherry. Arguing about the  
details of models whose main features haven't even been investigated is a  
futile exercise, to my current way of thinking. It's like arguing about what  
color dancing shoes all those angels on the pinhead are wearing.

Best,

Bill P.
