# The heart of the matter

**URL:** <http://discourse.iapct.org/t/the-heart-of-the-matter/11473>\
**Category:** CSG1993\
**Created:** [March 9, 1993, 11:10pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/the-heart-of-the-matter/11473 "1993-03-09T23:10:34Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 1\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Marken\_Richard\_S1](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/m/977dab/32.png) [@Marken\_Richard\_S1](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Marken_Richard_S1)\
**Post date:** [March 9, 1993, 11:10pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/the-heart-of-the-matter/11473/1 "1993-03-09T23:10:34Z")

</div>

[From Rick Marken (930309.1500)]

Bill Powers said:

> The only aspect of a control loop that is under reliable control,  
> therefore, is the sensor signal.

Hans Blom (930309) answers --

> In practice, this is true only if the sensor signal is ever-present and  
> noise-free. If the sensor signal contains (much) noise, as is often true in  
> engineering applications, some means is required to separate the signal  
> from the noise. You often call such means an input function. There are two  
> general approaches to getting rid of the noise: averaging over multiple  
> sensors (redundancy) or averaging over time (filtering).

But then it is this filtered sensory signal that is controlled, right?

> If the sensor signal may be absent for shorter or longer periods, a model  
> (in the sense of a built-in or acquired approximation of the object to be  
> controlled) is required that temporarily provides an alternative means of  
> pseudo-feedback. Such models are usually not highly accurate and therefore  
> drift will occur away from the optimal operating point.

And again, it is these model produced sensor signals that are controlled.

I don't get you point here, Hans. When a system is controlling (holding  
some aspect of the environment in a fixed or variable reference state  
while resisting the effects of disturbances) then it is the sensory  
(perceptual) signal (whatever its cause) is really controlled. If there  
is lots of noise or intermittancy in the system that there will be  
NO CONTROL. In this case the sensory signal is, indeed, NOT CONTROLLED  
because NONE OF THE VARIABLES IN THE LOOP ARE CONTROLLED.

The central insight of PCT is that WHEN THERE IS CONTROL THEN IT IS THE  
FUNCTIONAL EQUIVALENT OF THE SENSORY SIGNAL (PERCEPTION) THAT IS CONTROLLED.  
This is not just true of living systems; it is true of ALL NEGATIVE  
FEEDBACK CONTROL ORGANIZATIONS when they are IN CONTROL (that is, when  
their loop gain and dynamics are set appropriately so that the system  
is STABLE and keeping a variable at a fixed or varying reference against  
disturbance). The behavior of every single control system IS THE CONTROL  
OF PERCEPTION. The evidence for this fact about control systems is

1) mathematical; solving the simultaneous equations for a negative  
feedback control system we find that

p = r

(the perceptual signal, AND ONLY THE PERCEPTUAL SIGNAL, depends on  
the setting of the reference signal -- or setpoint for the controlled  
variable).

2) experimental; varying the sensory representation of the controlled  
variable changes the environmental level at which it is maintained.  
For example, wearing prism glasses changes the arm position that is  
counted as pointing at a target.

This fact about control system operation must be of little interest to  
a control engineer. But it is of FUNDEMENTAL significance a student of  
the behavior of living systems.

Your statement above gives the impression that you don't completely  
agree with the idea that control ALWAYS and ONLY involves the control  
of a sensory (perceptual) variables. It sounds like you are suggesting  
that other variables, besides sensory variables, can be controlled  
in a control loop. I would really like to know what these variables  
are because, if they exist, it would take an awful lot of the wind  
out of the PCT sails.

Best

Rick
