# WORDS & CONFUSION

**URL:** <http://discourse.iapct.org/t/words-confusion/12157>\
**Category:** CSG1993\
**Created:** [December 14, 1993, 7:11pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/words-confusion/12157 "1993-12-14T19:11:59Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 5\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Tom\_BOURBON3](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/t/85e7bf/32.png) [@Tom\_BOURBON3](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Tom_BOURBON3)\
**Post date:** [December 14, 1993, 7:11pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/words-confusion/12157/1 "1993-12-14T19:11:59Z")

</div>

Tom Bourbon [931214.1217]

More on words, confusion and confused again.

> [Martin Taylor 931210 12:10]  
> (Tom Bourbon 931209.1320)

I had posted in reply to Bob Clark.

Martin:

> Thanks, Tom. Now I have a much better appreciation of what it is that  
> raises antennae when you hear the word "dynamics." I dissociate what I  
> have been talking about from the kind of thing you present. It's not  
> the same objective or even domain of thought, despite perhaps using  
> methods with the same mathematical background. As Bill P says, having  
> a common mathematical background doesn't give things equal validity.
> 
> I guess I have to be more careful about what I presuppose in respect of  
> how people will interpret stuff. You have explained some reactions I  
> have up to now considered quite bizarre.

After that exchange, Rick and Martin began an exchange under the heading,  
"confused again," which seems to oscillate around the idea that calculus can  
be applied to the description and analysis of control systems, which  
comprise a subset of dynamic systems.

> **···**
>
> On my side, I am still trying to learn how Martin, and others, conceive of the relationships among PCT, information theory and the study of nonlinear dynamical systems. In a reply to Rick, Martin [Martin Taylor 931210 14:45] said:
> 
> "Before  
> joining CSG-L, I and some others here had been developing our own dynamical  
> approach to cognition, but it wasn't at all like what Tom quoted. We  
> were dealing with interacting physical systems, using as a text a set  
> of introductory books in what is called The Visual Mathematics Library.  
> They are called, misleadingly, "Dynamics: The Geometry of Behavior" by  
> Abraham and Shaw, Aerial Press 1984. I say misleadingly because the  
> behaviour in question has nothing to do with biological behaviour. It  
> is the behaviour of equations, and relates to all physical systems."
> 
> And he continued:
> 
> "The "dynamicists" I  
> referred to in my postings were people like Abraham and Shaw, probably  
> Prigogine and Nicolis, and people like that. Not people who look at the  
> various approaches to a human goal as defining an attractor dynamic (which  
> they do, in a loose sort of way) and treating that fact as an explanation  
> (which it isn't)."
> 
> I have not gotten hold of a copy of Abraham and Shaw, but I have seen, a  
> couple of years ago, Nicolis and Prigogine (\_Exploring complexity\_, 1989).  
> The dynamical psychologists I quoted also cite the people (A&S, N&P) cited  
> by Martin. The psychological dynamicists obviously see their work as an  
> extension or facet of mainstream dynamical analysis. I grow more confused!
> 
> In my search for more clues about possible connections among information  
> theory, dynamical analysis and PCT, I came across the following brief  
> article, from which I will quote a few passages. Martin, can you try to help  
> me see how the author's ideas might differ from yours, or resemble yours?
> 
> JAS Kelso (1992) "Theoretical concepts and strategies for understanding  
> perceptual-motor skill: From information capacity in closed systems to  
> self-organization in open, non-equilibrium systems," J. Exptl. Psy: General,  
> 121, 260-261.
> 
> This was published as part of the APA centennial celebration last year. It  
> is Kelso's invited "brief impression" of a "classic" paper published nearly  
> 40 years ago:
> 
> PM Fitts (1954) The information capacity of the human motor system in  
> controlling the amplitide of movement. Journal of Experimental Psychology,  
> 47, 381-391.
> 
> Fitts's article is often cited as containing the first recognition of the  
> idea that movement time is "affected by" both the distance and the required  
> precision of the movement. The article is often said to be the first, or  
> one of the first, to bring information theory, a la Shannon, into psychology.  
> In the article, Fitts stated what has come to be known as Fitts's Law:
> 
> Movement Time = a + (b \* [log base 2] of 2D/W),
> 
> where D = distance from starting position to center of target and W = width  
> of target.
> 
> In contrasting Fitts's article with recent work, Kelso writes about  
> recent conceptions of people as systems more complex than those studied  
> by Fitts. Recently, psychologists have "identified synergies and  
> coordinative structures" as solutions to the problem of coordination in  
> complex biological systems. To quote Kelso:
> 
> ============================================  
> "This does not necessarily mean informational complexity as found in the  
> Shannonian view, which stems from the statistical mechanics of closed  
> systems. Rather, the existence of synergies in open, nonequilibrium systems  
> implies a smaller set of informationally simple but functionally meaningful  
> chunks. Their representational structure may be said to correspond to  
> attractive collective states of a dissipative dynamical system. Semantic  
> information appears to be created in dynamical systems by a cooperativity  
> among participating elements."  
> . . .
> 
> "How might Fitts (1954) see the field now, nearly 40 years after his seminal  
> paper? On the information-theoretic side he would see several important  
> developments. Among these are efforts to extend information theory into  
> nonequilibrium systems by Haken (1988) in Stuttgart (TB: see the note below)  
> and explicit attempts along similar lines to incorporate semantic  
> information into computational theory and computer design by Shimizu's  
> group in Tokyo."
> 
> ============  
> Kelso's Note: "Haken (1988) developed the maximum entropy principle of  
> Jaynes. The latter has a nice ring to it for psychologists: 'If any  
> macrophenomenon is found to be reproducible, then it follows that all  
> microscopic details that were not under the experimenter's control must  
> be irrelevant for understanding and predicting it'" (Jaynes, 1985, p. 256).
> 
> H Haken (1988) \_Information and self-organization\_, Berlin:  
> Springer-Verlag.
> 
> # ET Jaynes (1985) Macroscopic prediction. In H Haken (Ed) \_Complex systems: operational approaches in neurobiology, physics and computers\_ (pp. 254-269). Berlin: Springer-Verlag.
> 
> Back to Kelso's text:
> 
> # "Some years ago . . . I suggested that the reason for the \*lawfulness\*, or regularity, evident in Fitts's Law was because the surface relation between movement time and amplitude emerges from harmonic basis functions (e.g., mass-spring dynamics) tailored by boundary conditions (e.g., spatial accuracy requirements). Guiard (in press) has recently produced quite compelling evidence along this line. In particular, he observed deviations from linearity (simple harmonic motion) in a cyclical aiming task as the tolerance or accuracy requirements were systematically increased. The relation identified by Fitts is lawlike, one assumes, because of the ubiquity of periodic motion (regular and irregular) in nature and the corresponding role of the (nonlinear) oscillator as an archetype of time-varying behavior. It is important to note that whether such a dynamical system exhibits postural states or discrete, rhythmical (or even chaotic) behavior depends solely on its parameters. In this view, Fitts's Law itself arises as a consequence of applying parameters to an underlying dynamical law created by the nervous system for a specific goal-directed action."
> 
> These brief quotes from a short commentary by Kelso provide some glimpses  
> of how closely the psychological dynamicists believe their work meshes  
> with that of information theorists and nonlinear systems dynamicists. For  
> example, twice Kelso cited the work of Hermann Haken. Haken has published  
> extensively on information theory and dynamical systems analysis, and on how  
> those areas are related. Kelso, Mandell and Schlesinger (1988) did a  
> Festschrift in his honor at the Center for Complex Systems, at Florida  
> Atlantic University. The papers are published as, \_Dynamical patterns in  
> complex systems\_, which is not readily available here.
> 
> All I have to show for my exploration is a clearer idea of the historical  
> links between information theory and nonlinear dynamical systems analysis,  
> and a greater sense of confusion over how either of those fields might apply  
> to PCT, other than at the level of abstract \*descriptions\* of the  
> superficial \*appearances\* produced by control systems as dynamic systems.  
> My faiure to see more to it than that does not mean there is nothing more,  
> only that I haven't been able to find it.
> 
> Martin, or anyone else, can you give me some help?
> 
> Until later,
> 
> Tom

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![\_Martin\_Taylor](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/_/a9adbd/32.png) [@\_Martin\_Taylor](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/_Martin_Taylor)\
**Post date:** [December 14, 1993, 9:12pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/words-confusion/12157/2 "1993-12-14T21:12:06Z")

</div>

[Martin Taylor 931214 16:00]  
(Tom Bourbon 931214.1217)

> On my side, I am still trying to learn how Martin, and others, conceive of  
> the relationships among PCT, information theory and the study of nonlinear  
> dynamical systems.

I hope my reply to Rick this afternoon has cleared up the PCT\<-\>dynamics  
link. I had not anticipated the information-theory tarbaby to creep so  
close, since it had not seemed anywhere nearby in the preceding discussion.  
But here it is again. Indeed, information theory is appropriately applied  
in dynamical analysis, attractors being manifestations of the destruction  
of information about prior states. Control systems are more appropriate  
to locally divergent systems, in that they, too, reduce the information  
available about prior states, whereas the divergences actually increase  
it. But this kind of thing doesn't seem to have much to do with what  
Kelse is talking about.

I'll look up the Kelso paper you reference. I, too, am confused by the  
sections you quote, and I simply don't make sense of phrases such as:

"the existence of synergies in open, nonequilibrium systems  
implies a smaller set of informationally simple but functionally meaningful  
chunks."

Or much of the rest of what you quote. And I suspect I will have to find  
the Haken references, too. My understanding of information theory is much  
more down-to-earth, and it is based on what is in the Prologue paper  
you picked up in Durango.

The second part of your Kelso quote, about the mass-spring dynamics,  
seems irrelevant to information and control, as cited. And the section

"This does not necessarily mean informational complexity as found in the  
Shannonian view, which stems from the statistical mechanics of closed  
systems. Rather, the existence of synergies in open, nonequilibrium systems  
implies a smaller set of informationally simple but functionally meaningful  
chunks. Their representational structure may be said to correspond to  
attractive collective states of a dissipative dynamical system. Semantic  
information appears to be created in dynamical systems by a cooperativity  
among participating elements."

is quite opposed to my view. I accept the Shannon approach, but based  
on the subjective probability distribution (all that is available to  
real physical systems). The Shannon approach does not mean physically  
closed systems at all. The last quoted sentence implies that Kelso is  
thinking of something entirely different, and it sounds a bit mystical  
to me.

> The psychological dynamicists obviously see their work as an  
> extension or facet of mainstream dynamical analysis. I grow more confused!

I have a suspicion that the confusion might be lessened if you think of  
what they are doing as looking for what Dag calls a description, rather  
than a model. But I'll look up Kelso. I'd hate to be put back into a  
bag from which I thought I had escaped, at least not until I know where  
the bag's opening is.

Martin

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Tom\_BOURBON3](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/t/85e7bf/32.png) [@Tom\_BOURBON3](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Tom_BOURBON3)\
**Post date:** [December 15, 1993, 6:13pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/words-confusion/12157/3 "1993-12-15T18:13:29Z")

</div>

> From Tom Bourbon [931215.1047]

> [Martin Taylor 931214 16:00]  
> (Tom Bourbon 931214.1217)

Me:

> > On my side, I am still trying to learn how Martin, and others, conceive of  
> > the relationships among PCT, information theory and the study of nonlinear  
> > dynamical systems.

Martin:

> I hope my reply to Rick this afternoon has cleared up the PCT\<-\>dynamics  
> link.

It helped me form a better idea of what you think about the link, but left  
me with some lingering uncertainties.

> I had not anticipated the information-theory tarbaby to creep so  
> close, since it had not seemed anywhere nearby in the preceding discussion.  
> But here it is again.

I'm sorry you think of this as a tarbaby. If "it" (the question of whether  
information theory implies PCT and, if so, in which ways) is a tarbaby to  
you, remember that in the Uncle Remus stories the tarbaby most often ended  
up sticking to its maker, rather than the intended victim. I am merely  
trying to understand the possible relationships among information theory  
(IT), dynamical analyses (DA), and PCT. It is clear that some people,  
including a few on this net, think there are important relationships. I  
recall that you introduced the IT-PCT linkage to the net "long ago," if  
I can use that phrase in reference to csg-l. To me, the short piece by  
Kelso seemed to provide clues about how someone else thinks about the IT-DA  
connection and I was curious about your thoughts on the article.

I appreciate your thoughtful reply to my questions, and I was pleased to  
learn that you see some of the same problems as I, in the Kelso article.  
Still, in some places where you see clear differences between Kelso's ideas  
and yours, I cannot find the distinction. After reading your post, I now  
suspect that one of the biggest impediments to my seeing the same  
distinctions as you arises from the similarity of your writing style to the  
ones often used by IT-DA psychologists. I will use the following brief  
example, quoted from your post, to illustrate my point:

Martin:

> Indeed, information theory is appropriately applied  
> in dynamical analysis, attractors being manifestations of the destruction  
> of information about prior states.

My first reaction is that this sentence looks very much like what I see in  
the IT-DA literature. At the most obvious level, you are saying that indeed  
the two "approaches" do apply to the same systems. My problem is at another  
level. I see you attaching concrete meanings and roles to what I believe  
are metaphorical terms, just the sort of thing I see in IT-DA psychology.  
You seem to be saying:

There are Prior States (PSs). There is Information "about" PSs (IPSs).  
Something (X) "destroys" IPSs. (Destruction, the noun, refers to the  
transitive verb, destroy, which implies that an agent acts to destroy an  
object of the action.) When X destroys IPSs, there are "manifestations" of  
the destruction. The manifestations are "attractors."

Martin, I am not reying to be difficult or cute. I \*do\* admit to being a  
very simple-minded person when it comes to material like this. I know your  
sentence was "short hand" for many other ideas; however, when I encounter a  
sentence like the one I quoted, I \*must\* try to identify objects and  
predicates -- the agents, actions and objects of actions. In the present  
case I am left wondering what does the destroying; what is destroyed; if  
IPSs is destroyed do the PSs themselves survive, or are they also destroyed;  
is the act or process of destruction "manifest," or is it the \*result\* of  
the destruction that is manifest; exactly what is "a manifestation," why  
should it should be renamed "an attractor," and what is gained in the  
renaming; is that all that most people have in mind when they speak about  
attractors.

Somewhere in there is something that seems to be of great significance to  
you. I am trying to understand exactly what it might be. The fact that  
I am thoroughly lost, right at the start, makes it impossible for me to  
appreciate the distinctions you try to draw elsewhere in your post.

Me:

> > The psychological dynamicists obviously see their work as an  
> > extension or facet of mainstream dynamical analysis. I grow more confused!

Martin:

> I have a suspicion that the confusion might be lessened if you think of  
> what they are doing as looking for what Dag calls a description, rather  
> than a model. But I'll look up Kelso. I'd hate to be put back into a  
> bag from which I thought I had escaped, at least not until I know where  
> the bag's opening is.

It is one thing for me to think in those terms about what they do, but that  
would not be a proper construal in the numerous instances where they write  
about these ideas as models and mechanisms.

I'm not trying to put you into, or back into, a bag, Martin. PCT has run  
hard up against information theory and dynamical systems analysis, many  
times. Your posts have helped me realize there are some major differences  
of opinion among those who write favorably about IT, and DA, and IT-DA  
linkages. But that realization does not answer all of my questions about  
whether or to what degree IT and DA are important in PCT. I seem to be  
stuck on the metaphorical appearances of it all.

Thanks, for your willingness (albeit sometimes grudging willingness) to pick  
up the tarbaby. If we reach a resting place in this discussion, I'll share  
some of the very effective lemon-based solvent we often use to remove the  
inevitable tar left on our feet after a walk on the Texas beach.

Until later,

Tom

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![\_Martin\_Taylor](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/_/a9adbd/32.png) [@\_Martin\_Taylor](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/_Martin_Taylor)\
**Post date:** [December 16, 1993, 12:29am UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/words-confusion/12157/4 "1993-12-16T00:29:25Z")

</div>

[Martin Taylor 931215 19:30]  
(Tom Bourbon 931215.1047)

> I'm not trying to put you into, or back into, a bag, Martin. PCT has run  
> hard up against information theory and dynamical systems analysis, many  
> times. Your posts have helped me realize there are some major differences  
> of opinion among those who write favorably about IT, and DA, and IT-DA  
> linkages. But that realization does not answer all of my questions about  
> whether or to what degree IT and DA are important in PCT. I seem to be  
> stuck on the metaphorical appearances of it all.
> 
> Thanks, for your willingness (albeit sometimes grudging willingness) to pick  
> up the tarbaby. If we reach a resting place in this discussion, I'll share  
> some of the very effective lemon-based solvent we often use to remove the  
> inevitable tar left on our feet after a walk on the Texas beach.

I have written to Tom privately on this posting, offering (somewhat  
reluctantly) a private dialogue on the issue. I am not prepared to  
go into a public discussion on information theory and PCT, given the  
quality and tenor of the last go-round on the issue, and the evidence  
provided by the current "physics" discussion that a new attempt would  
have no different result. I have neither sufficient frustration tolerance  
nor a sufficiently low workload (at my "day job"). Maybe later, maybe not.

Martin

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Tom\_BOURBON3](http://discourse.iapct.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/t/85e7bf/32.png) [@Tom\_BOURBON3](http://discourse.iapct.org/u/Tom_BOURBON3)\
**Post date:** [December 16, 1993, 9:46pm UTC](http://discourse.iapct.org/t/words-confusion/12157/5 "1993-12-16T21:46:21Z")

</div>

> From Tom Bourbon [931216.1544]

> [Martin Taylor 931215 19:30]  
> (Tom Bourbon 931215.1047)

Tom, then:

> > I'm not trying to put you into, or back into, a bag, Martin. PCT has run  
> > hard up against information theory and dynamical systems analysis, many  
> > times. Your posts have helped me realize there are some major differences  
> > of opinion among those who write favorably about IT, and DA, and IT-DA  
> > linkages. But that realization does not answer all of my questions about  
> > whether or to what degree IT and DA are important in PCT. I seem to be  
> > stuck on the metaphorical appearances of it all.
> > 
> > Thanks, for your willingness (albeit sometimes grudging willingness) to pick  
> > up the tarbaby. If we reach a resting place in this discussion, I'll share  
> > some of the very effective lemon-based solvent we often use to remove the  
> > inevitable tar left on our feet after a walk on the Texas beach.

Martin:

> I have written to Tom privately on this posting, offering (somewhat  
> reluctantly) a private dialogue on the issue. I am not prepared to  
> go into a public discussion on information theory and PCT, given the  
> quality and tenor of the last go-round on the issue, and the evidence  
> provided by the current "physics" discussion that a new attempt would  
> have no different result. I have neither sufficient frustration tolerance  
> nor a sufficiently low workload (at my "day job"). Maybe later, maybe not.

There is no need for a private dialogue, Martin, but thank you for the  
reluctant offer. It is not my intention to encroach on your limited time.  
The paragraphs from me, that you quoted above, were part of a post in which  
I described my attempts to understand the distinctions you draw between your  
ideas and those of people like Kelso and Turvey. My recent efforts along  
that line were prompted by the recent round of discussion here on csg-l,  
in which dynamical systems analysis (DSA) emerged once again, along with a  
mix of implications and assertions that DSA could do much to inform PCT.  
(I do not attribute all of those implications and assertions to you.)

The discussion seemed to be falling back into some of the familiar ruts. In  
an attempt to add a different perspective, I quoted material by Kelso  
and Turvey and some of their associates, in which they speak of human  
performance and analyze it, or talk about it, "in the language of DSA."  
(They often use the phrase I show here in quotes.) One article in  
particular described Kelso's ideas about how information theory (IT) and  
DSA pertain to human performance (see Tom Bourbon [931214.1217]). Like  
Kelso, although perhaps for different reasons, you sometimes express a  
belief that IT and DSA do, or should, play important roles in PCT. One of  
your self-assigned projects of long-standing is to determine if you can  
prepare either a demonstration or a proof that PCT \*necessarily\* follows  
from IT.

In your reply [Martin Taylor 931214 16:00] to the post in which I quoted  
Kelso on IT-DSA, you declared that his ideas and yours were quite different.  
In my reply to you (Tom Bourbon [931215.1047]), I cited a brief example of  
why I was unable to see all of the distinctions you were trying to draw.  
In particular, I could not follow this comment of yours about IT and DSA:

Martin:

> Indeed, information theory is appropriately applied  
> in dynamical analysis, attractors being manifestations of the destruction  
> of information about prior states.

My non-understanding extended to the subsequent sentence (quoted below),  
which I did not include in my reply. In this sentence, I believe you were  
indicating that, like attractors, control systems also destroy, or at least  
reduce, information about prior states. You said:

> Control systems are more appropriate  
> to locally divergent systems, in that they, too, reduce the information  
> available about prior states, whereas the divergences actually increase  
> it.

Once more, I confess my inability to follow your reasoning, which is in part  
due to my problem with disentangling the several agents, actions and objects  
of actions, that are declared or implied in your passage. I am disappointed  
that you have elected to withdraw from the discussion of these topics on the  
net. Surely I am not the only subscriber who would like to understand your  
thoughts on the links you see among and between IT, DSA and PCT. I am  
especially disappointed that you are ending the public discussion with the  
thought that to pursue it would be futile, given:

> the  
> quality and tenor of the last go-round on the issue, and the evidence  
> provided by the current "physics" discussion that a new attempt would  
> have no different result.

Concerning the discussion of "physics," you have concluded [Martin Taylor  
931215 17:20] that:

> I don't have the  
> tolerance Mary ascribes (with good reason) to Bill, giving kindergarten  
> lessons day after day. After this, forget it. As you and I have all  
> said, it really doesn't matter for the dynamical analysis of control  
> systems whether you understand the thermodynamic ramifications.

When your tolerance is renewed, or when you complete your proof that PCT  
necessarily follows from IT, I am certain you will find some of us  
kindergarteners still willing to listen. 🙂

Until later,

Tom
