Book Review: Making Sense of Behavior

I have posted to Amazon.com and to my web site a review of Bill's book
"Making Sense of Behavior." The text is reproduced below.

If you buy only one book this year it should be Making Sense of Behavior by
William T. Powers. Powers' book is subtitled The Meaning of Control and in
it he presents, in plain and persuasive language, his view of human beings
and their behavior. His view? We are all "autonomous control systems it
is our nature to seek goals and oppose disturbances [to the attainment and
maintenance of our goals]."

In his book Powers does what other theorists and theories don't, namely, he
gives us an explanation of the human phenomenon that is technically
satisfying and, at the same time, an explanation that resonates with our
deeply held notions about ourselves. Who won't like this book? The same
pompous airbags who have seen fit to saddle us all with one empty-headed
theory after another about the nature of human beings and their
behavior. The truth, like quality and beauty, is something we all know
when we see it. You'll recognize the truth in Powers' book.

Powers is no intellectual slouch. An engineer by training and a scientist
by calling, his approach is as intellectually demanding and as
scientifically rigorous as any to be found. Nor is his theory of recent or
easy vintage. He has been hard at work developing it for almost half a
century. He first articulated it in a 1973 book titled Behavior: The
Control of Perception and he has elaborated it in various papers since then.

Powers' central thesis is simple enough: All we know of our world we know
through our perceptions. We act, then, not to control the world but to
control our perceptions of it. Hence, behavior as the control of
perception. Best of all, Powers provides a simple, elegant experiment
requiring nothing more than two rubber bands and two people that we can use
to test his theory. It is difficult to argue with.

So what? What are the practical implications of Powers' theory? Well, for
one thing, the transactions between employer and employee need to be
negotiated instead of commanded or demanded. If that seems obvious,
consider this: for the most part, so do the transactions between parent or
teacher and child. Remember, we are all of us "autonomous control
systems," even the children among us. For another, Powers offers an
interesting if not novel approach to conflict resolution, namely, taking it
"up a level." (I leave to the readers of Powers' book the fun of
discovering of what that means.) Finally, in the midst of all this
autonomy is the unavoidable conclusion that we are inescapably accountable
for our own behavior. (Management will both love and hate that one.)

The bottom line of Powers' message is plain and profound: I am in control
of me. That's all there is and that's enough. Moreover, the inevitable
consequence of attempting to control others is conflict.

But why take my word for it? At $14.95, Power's book is a bargain. Buy
it, read it and then you tell me what you think. I'll post your reviews on
my web site.
Fred Nickols
The Distance Consulting Company
"Assistance at A Distance"
http://home.att.net/~nickols/distance.htm
nickols@worldnet.att.net
(609) 490-0095

[From Bill Powers (2000.01.31.0008 MST)]

I have posted to Amazon.com and to my web site a review of Bill's book
"Making Sense of Behavior." The text is reproduced below.

Thanks for that, Fred.

Best,

Bill P.

I don't know. Sound like a "good' theory, but for me I just see Powers as
another writer looking deeper than you have to. It's quite simple. The way
I see it is that we are each unique individuals with a special survival kit.
What we have packed in it is where we are. We need a system of social
rules, and consequences that are equally distributed and carried out. There
will never be a society that has no social problems. That is prophesy!
Well, we don't have agree, but we have to learn to agree to be able to
disagree and carry out our mission. "Si Se Puede."

···

-----Original Message-----
        From: Fred Nickols [SMTP:nickols@WORLDNET.ATT.NET]
        Sent: Sunday, January 30, 2000 8:46 PM
        To: CSGNET@POSTOFFICE.CSO.UIUC.EDU
        Subject: Book Review: Making Sense of Behavior

        I have posted to Amazon.com and to my web site a review of Bill's
book
        "Making Sense of Behavior." The text is reproduced below.

        If you buy only one book this year it should be Making Sense of
Behavior by
        William T. Powers. Powers' book is subtitled The Meaning of Control
and in
        it he presents, in plain and persuasive language, his view of human
beings
        and their behavior. His view? We are all "autonomous control
systems it
        is our nature to seek goals and oppose disturbances [to the
attainment and
        maintenance of our goals]."

        In his book Powers does what other theorists and theories don't,
namely, he
        gives us an explanation of the human phenomenon that is technically
        satisfying and, at the same time, an explanation that resonates with
our
        deeply held notions about ourselves. Who won't like this book? The
same
        pompous airbags who have seen fit to saddle us all with one
empty-headed
        theory after another about the nature of human beings and their
        behavior. The truth, like quality and beauty, is something we all
know
        when we see it. You'll recognize the truth in Powers' book.

        Powers is no intellectual slouch. An engineer by training and a
scientist
        by calling, his approach is as intellectually demanding and as
        scientifically rigorous as any to be found. Nor is his theory of
recent or
        easy vintage. He has been hard at work developing it for almost
half a
        century. He first articulated it in a 1973 book titled Behavior:
The
        Control of Perception and he has elaborated it in various papers
since then.

        Powers' central thesis is simple enough: All we know of our world we
know
        through our perceptions. We act, then, not to control the world but
to
        control our perceptions of it. Hence, behavior as the control of
        perception. Best of all, Powers provides a simple, elegant
experiment
        requiring nothing more than two rubber bands and two people that we
can use
        to test his theory. It is difficult to argue with.

        So what? What are the practical implications of Powers' theory?
Well, for
        one thing, the transactions between employer and employee need to be
        negotiated instead of commanded or demanded. If that seems obvious,
        consider this: for the most part, so do the transactions between
parent or
        teacher and child. Remember, we are all of us "autonomous
control
        systems," even the children among us. For another, Powers offers an
        interesting if not novel approach to conflict resolution, namely,
taking it
        "up a level." (I leave to the readers of Powers' book the fun of
        discovering of what that means.) Finally, in the midst of all this
        autonomy is the unavoidable conclusion that we are inescapably
accountable
        for our own behavior. (Management will both love and hate that
one.)

        The bottom line of Powers' message is plain and profound: I am in
control
        of me. That's all there is and that's enough. Moreover, the
inevitable
        consequence of attempting to control others is conflict.

        But why take my word for it? At $14.95, Power's book is a bargain.
Buy
        it, read it and then you tell me what you think. I'll post your
reviews on
        my web site.
        Fred Nickols
        The Distance Consulting Company
        "Assistance at A Distance"
        http://home.att.net/~nickols/distance.htm
        nickols@worldnet.att.net
        (609) 490-0095