[From Fred Nickols
(2010.05.24.1052 PDT)]
I will be responding later today
to the lists where I posed the thermostat question. I intend providing
the following explanations regarding the answers. Does anyone spot any
flaws in my explanations?
Does the thermostat act to control room temperature?
Technically, the answer is no. Room temperature is
affected as a result of the furnace adding or not adding warm air to the room
via the ducts from the furnace. And the thermostat does turn the furnace
on and off. But, in the strict sense of “control” as meaning
to bring something (in this case, room temperature,) to a specified value and
keeping it there, the answer is no, the thermostat does not control room
temperature.
Does the thermostat act to control furnace operation?
Again technically, the answer is no. It is true that
the thermostat switches the furnace on and off but this is simply a means of
starting or stopping the flow of warm air so as to control something else.
Does the thermostat act to control the sensed (i.e.,
measured) temperature?
Yes. The actions of the thermostat (turning the
furnace on and off) start and stop the flow of warm air into the room.
The thermostat has a sensing device that measures the temperature in the
immediate vicinity of the thermostat (which is why thermostat placement is so
important). The “immediate vicinity” of the thermostat
is not the same as the larger room. In fact, one can place a lamp or a
candle in the vicinity of the thermostat and the sensed or measured temperature
will be decidedly different from the temperature measured elsewhere in the
room. What the thermostat acts to control is the temperature it senses or
measures. It exercises this control by turning the furnace on or off.
Does the thermostat act to control the desired or set point
temperature?
No. The set point temperature is controlled or
adjusted by a human being who slides a lever to the desired value or, in the
case of a digital thermostat, enters the desired temperature by pressing a
button.
Regards,
Fred Nickols
Managing
Partner
Distance Consulting LLC
1558 Coshocton
Ave - Suite 303
Mount Vernon,
OH 43050-5416
www.nickols.us
fred@nickols.us
“Assistance at a
Distance”
···
From: Fred Nickols
[mailto:fred@nickols.us]
Sent: Sunday, May 23, 2010 7:18 AM
To: ‘Control Systems Group Network (CSGnet)’
Subject: Control, Thermostats and Language
[Fred Nickols (2010.05.23.0717 PDT)]
As I indicated I would, I posted the question below to some
internet groups.
Whenever the
subject of control comes up, someone is almost sure to introduce the
thermostat. Here’s a question for you. Pick only one
response. If you share your response with me or the list, I will tally
them and then share the “correct” response.
A thermostat acts
to control:
a. Room temperature
b. Furnace or A/C
operation (on/off)
c. The temperature it
senses
d. The temperature
that has been set
My
purposes were (a) to see how people responded and (b) to use the item to make
the point that what is controlled are perceptions; in the case of the
thermostat, that’s the sensed temperature.
So
far, no one has chosen c – the “correct” answer. Most
choose b and one has chosen a. Two chose d. Two people opted for
all four choices and one responded with an explanation of how a thermostat
works but did not choose a response. I expect more responses today and
tomorrow.
I
think there is a problem with language; specifically, with the term
“control.” For many people it does not carry any technical
meaning such as “bring a controlled variable to some reference
value.” For these same people it does seem to mean something along
the lines of “I can make it do what I want.” For them,
that’s turning the furnace or A/C on or off, or bringing the room
temperature to some set value, or even setting the desired temperature.
They view themselves as controlling all these things.
Moreover,
even with the technical usage, there is a blurred line between what the
thermostat controls and what I am trying to control. The thermostat
controls sensed temperature (i.e., it operates the furnace or A/C so as to
bring the sensed temperature to the setpoint temperature). I, on the
other hand, am trying to control what I sense to be the room temperature (i.e.,
which I do by setting the setpoint to a temperature I want and leave the rest
of the task to the furnace or A/C).
I
have a hunch that sorting all this out will be tricky but worthwhile.
Regards,
Fred Nickols
Managing
Partner
Distance Consulting LLC
1558 Coshocton
Ave - Suite 303
Mount Vernon,
OH 43050-5416
fred@nickols.us
“Assistance at a
Distance”