From [Marc Abrams (9802081320)]
Dan Miller (980207 & others)
Hi Dan,
You want observations, let me give you one (not that I think It'll
make a difference :-)) About 6 months ago I probably would have agreed
with your assessment ( "seen" the same things) about the arrogance of
some of the people on this list, especially one Rick Marken. But over
this time period I have (to quote John Belushi from the movie the
_Blues Brothers_) "seen the light".
There is _no_ doubt in my mind that people have left this list because
of what _they_ _perceived_ (not dissimilar to you) about Rick's
"attitude" But lets not forget that it's all _perception_.
Thats real important because _what_ _I_ "see" (perceive) now is
different that what I saw (perceived) 6 months ago. Outside of
becoming a bit more tactful over the last couple of weeks (I wonder
how long it'll last :-)) I don't think Rick's "message" has changed
much. In fact I went through posts of the last 18 months and he seems
pretty consistent to me ( with or without the sarcasm :-)) in what hes
saying. Rick is a big CV man. Some of us like legs, some of us like
tushes, some breasts, Rick happens to like CV's (not to the _total_
exclusion of those other things :-)) In fact Rick believes that
understanding and _knowing_ about CV's is the _most_ important thing
to know if you want to _know_ what individuals care about and want.
It's real basic. If your gonna talk about _anything_ we _do_ (act,
behave, anticipate, whatever) It _must_ be _based_.on _what_ we are
controlling for. Thats the main reason for the harangues against
conventional research. Where are the CV's ( Remember that Wendys
commercial, _Wheres the beef?_ :-)) Without _knowing_ _what the CV's
are _everything_ else is a moot point when it comes to behavior. Now,
if you _don't_ believe that the PCT model is an accurate one then it's
all BS. There is _NO_ middle ground.
I have _never_ heard Bill, Rick or anyone on this list say that PCT
was the second tablet given to Moses In fact just the opposite. What
Rick has been _pleading_ for ( and at times getting real pissed of
about :-)) is for legitimate (falseafiable) research. PCT is in its
_infancy_ Only the very basic mechanisms are known (thanks to the
experiments of Bill, Rick, Tom and others) and understood. The
question then becomes how do we _build_ on what has been done. If the
research is not _BASED_ on what we are controlling for then we
_cannot_ add _anything_ to the PCT literature. If you believe in other
behavioral mechanisms accounting for our actions beside the control
loop, fine. You also might want to consider joining the Flat Earth
Society, I believe it still exists.
A lot of work needs to be done. The hierarchy needs to be explored
more fully. I think "learning" needs to be more fully explained But,
it _must_ be done within the context of the control model ( not the
S-R model, or Cognitive, or Person Centered, or Action Science, or
whatever:-))
In wrapping up Dan, _I_ don't "see" (perceive) arrogance. ( I am not
saying it doesn't exist in someone else's perception (namely yours
:-)) I see a rock solid commitment to the _basic_ PCT model and an
equal commitment to exploring and expanding on our understanding of
the _PCT_ model.
Best of luck in your future work. Hope you find what your looking for.
Marc ..