[From Rick Marken (931101.1300)]
cc to Gavan Lintern
Gavan Lintern (931101.0836) to Martin Taylor --
I think the argument goes as follows (although I do not remember seeing this
anywhere in print): What appears to be a closed loop feedback system will
succumb to a more detailed analysis,
PCT is not based on the fact that organisms "appear to be closed-loop
feedback systems". It is based on the fact that organisms CONTROL; they
maintain variables in autonomously determined states despite variable
disturbances to and/or changes in the organism's effects on those
variables. The only KNOWN organizaton of functional components that
can CONTROL (according to PCT) is a closed-loop negative feedback
control system. A large part of what PCT does is explain the many
surprising and enlightening implications of this fact.
much in the sense that biological
temperature control can succumb to a more detailed analyses.
Does this mean that there is a WORKING model of the biological
temperature control system that is NOT a closed loop negative
feedback control system? I think it would be VERY helpful for
PCTers to see both this analysis of the temperature control
system and the evidence that supports the analysis.
A focus on
feedback concepts might impede a detailed understanding of the process.
What process is being referred to here? If the process is _control_
then how could feedback concepts impede detailed understanding?
Feedback concepts are REQUIRED for detailed understanding. Without
feedback, there is no control. Am I wrong about this? If so, why?
The appropriate concepts to pursue these understandings are found in
dynamical systems theory.
Can you point me to a WORKING dynamical systems model of ANY control
process? I've never found one. I started looking for such models
in the eary 1980s but abandoned the search some time ago. I prefer
computer programmed implementations of such dynamical systems -- my
skill with differential equations is pretty modest.
Dynamics (chaos, self organization) may be a trendy science.
Just because something is trendy doesn't mean it's wrong. Actually,
I think a case can be made for the notion that chaos and self-
organization are trendy (as models of behavior) BECUASE they are
fundementally wrong. The proof that these models are wrong is the
fact that they don't behave like living systems. While some of the
behavior of chaotic and self-organizing systems is SUPERFICIALLY
similar to that of living systems, PCT shows that the similarity
disappears when you start applying disturbances or changing the
relationship between the system and its environment. Another way
of saying this is as follows: the PCTer is not convinced that
chaotic or self-organizing systems CONTROL.
Best
Rick